GSTAT · Thane ● Remanded Devendrakumar Fuljibai Parmar v Eak Traders. 2026-juristway.com-3737-GSTAT(Thane)-GST 19 November 2026 In Devendrakumar Fuljibai Parmar v. Eak Traders, 2026-juristway.com-3737-GSTAT(Thane)-GST , where an exporter flagged as a risky exporter was refused IGST refunds of Rs. 62,10,143 and Rs. 19,89,832 because its suppliers were found non-existent or had registrations cancelled, and the Appellate Authority allowed the refunds on 30.09.2025, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Thane Bench noted that a show cause notice under Section 74 for recovery of the same credit of Rs. 81,99,975 was pending (paras 6.2–6.3). The Hon'ble Tribunal held that refund is a consequential relief that cannot be granted while its foundation is under an active demand for fraud, so the appellate order was premature (paras 6.5–6.6). The original orders rejecting the refunds outright, without awaiting the Section 74 outcome, were equally flawed (para 6.7). Both sets of orders were set aside and the claims remanded for de novo decision, to be kept in abeyance or consolidated with the Section 74 proceedings and decided on their final outcome (paras 7.1–7.6). GSTAT · Prayagraj ● Allowed Sangha Erectors Private Limited v Deputy Commissioner, State Tax Hamirpur Uttar Pradesh & Ors. 2026-juristway.com-3736-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST 19 November 2026 In Sangha Erectors Private Limited v. Deputy Commissioner, State Tax, 2026-juristway.com-3736-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST , where demands for two years were raised on the Uttar Pradesh registration of a multi-State contractor by comparing Form 26AS with the aggregate returns of four and five State registrations, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Prayagraj Bench allowed the appeals, deciding four issues. Jurisdictional foundation (for the taxpayer): The Uttar Pradesh returns tallied; no site, recipient, invoice or payer in the State was identified, yet the whole difference was taxed as intra-State supply. The notices lacked the jurisdictional fact (paras 15–16). Burden and Form 26AS (for the taxpayer): Section 155 casts the burden only for input tax credit; Form 26AS may prompt inquiry but is not evidence of the supplies of a particular registration (paras 17–18). Suppression (for the Revenue): Silence through an intimation, DRC-01A, notice and three reminders, with shifting explanations, was deliberate withholding amounting to suppression with intent to evade (paras 19–20). Nexus (for the taxpayer): That intent was not shown to relate to Uttar Pradesh tax, so Section 74 failed (paras 21–22). Order: Remand declined; orders set aside, notices quashed for this registration, and refund of pre-deposit to be considered within thirty days (paras 23–24, Order). SC ● Dismissed The Gem and Jewellery Export Promotion Council v The State of Maharashtra and Others. 2026-juristway.com-3735-SC-VAT/CST 19 November 2026 In Gem and Jewellery Export Promotion Council v. State of Maharashtra, 2026-juristway.com-3735-SC-VAT/CST , where a company under Section 25 of the Companies Act, 1956 organised the India International Jewellery Show as a trade-only platform with screened visitors and a paid entry fee, and entertainment duty was levied, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the exhibitions fall within Section 2(a) and are exigible under Section 3 (para 20). Reading the inclusive definition literally, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the words “to which persons are admitted for payment” are the deciding factor for each of the five listed events (paras 19–20). Entry was on payment and the exhibition showcased the merchandise of participating traders; its business-to-business character did not take it out of the definition, and the application and screening procedure could serve other purposes such as security (para 20). The Hon'ble Supreme Court expressed full agreement with the judgment of the Bombay High Court dated 04.03.2013 and dismissed the appeal (paras 20–21). HC · Allahabad ● Other M/s Amritvarsha Industries Limited v Deputy Commissioner State Tax and Another 2026-juristway.com-3734-HC(Allahabad)-GST 18 November 2026 In Amritvarsha Industries Limited v. Deputy Commissioner State Tax, 2026-juristway.com-3734-HC(Allahabad)-GST , where the taxpayer challenged a show cause notice in FORM GST DRC-01 dated 28.09.2026 for FY 2022-23 on the ground that no case for proceedings under Section 74 was made out, the Standing Counsel placed written instructions admitting that the notice had been issued erroneously (paras 3–5). The Hon'ble Allahabad High Court disposed of the writ petition with the observation that the notice may be dropped, with liberty to the Revenue to issue a fresh notice subject to limitation being available (paras 6–7). GSTAT · Hyderabad ● Other Timmasarti Venkateswara Rao v ARQ Electricals. 2026-juristway.com-3733-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST 18 November 2026 In Timmasarti Venkateswara Rao v. ARQ Electricals, 2026-juristway.com-3733-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST , where registration cancelled for non-filing of returns in FY 2023-24 was restored after the Appellate Authority condoned delay beyond Section 107(4) on the strength of orders of the Hon'ble Telangana High Court, and the Department appealed after implementing the order, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench applied its common orders dated 18.09.2026. The Hon'ble Tribunal held that the Appellate Authority had exceeded its statutory power, since orders under Article 226 on their own facts do not enlarge it (paras 9.1, 11–11.1). The Department, however, having restored the registration, could not attack the order it had acted upon, and no effective relief could be granted (paras 9.2, 11.2). The appeal was disposed of as infructuous and not maintainable (paras 12–14). GSTAT · Hyderabad ● Other Channa Reddy Donthireddy v Sri Aditya Hotels & Resorts. 2026-juristway.com-3732-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST 18 November 2026 In Channa Reddy Donthireddy v. Sri Aditya Hotels & Resorts, 2026-juristway.com-3732-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST , where the Appellate Authority, by order dated 13.01.2022, restored the registration of an outdoor catering business cancelled for six months' default in GSTR-3B, directing verification only of returns and tax, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench held that the Appellate Authority erred in ignoring the proviso to Rule 23(1) (paras 10–10.2, 12). The Hon'ble Tribunal held that the Department could collect interest and late fee under Sections 50 and 47, should use Section 79 for admitted dues, and imposed a penalty of Rs. 10,000 (paras 11–11.2). The appellate order was modified to that extent; the taxpayer did not appear (paras 6, 12–14). GSTAT · Hyderabad ● Other Timmasarti Venkateswara Rao v Sri Karani Visions / Vijaya Laxmi Guttikonda. 2026-juristway.com-3731-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST 18 November 2026 In Timmasarti Venkateswara Rao v. Sri Karani Visions, 2026-juristway.com-3731-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST , where the Appellate Authority, relying on Southern Enterprises and Chenna Krishnama Charyulu Karampudi of the Hon'ble Telangana High Court, condoned delay beyond the period in Section 107(4) in an appeal against cancellation of registration, and the Department restored the registration and then appealed, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench followed its common orders Nos. 04 to 19/COURT-II/HYD/2026 dated 18.09.2026. On the first issue, the Hon'ble Tribunal held that the Appellate Authority is a creature of statute and exceeded Section 107(4); writ orders on their own facts lay down no general rule (paras 9.1, 11–11.1). On the second, the Department, having implemented the order and altered the taxpayer's position, could not challenge it, and no effective relief could be granted (paras 9.2, 11.2). The appeal was disposed of as infructuous and not maintainable (paras 12–14). GSTAT · Hyderabad ● Other Md Qamaruddin Khan v NF Hbots Robotics Private Limited. 2026-juristway.com-3730-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST 18 November 2026 In Md Qamaruddin Khan v. NF Hbots Robotics Private Limited, 2026-juristway.com-3730-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST , where the Appellate Authority, by order dated 02.12.2021, restored the registration of an information technology services provider cancelled for six months' default in GSTR-3B, directing only verification of returns and tax, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench held that the proviso to Rule 23(1) had been ignored (paras 10–10.2, 12). The Hon'ble Tribunal left the restoration undisturbed, held the Department free to collect interest and late fee under Sections 50 and 47 and to use Section 79 for admitted dues, and imposed a penalty of Rs. 10,000 (paras 11–11.2). The appellate order was modified to that extent; the taxpayer did not appear (paras 6, 12–14). GSTAT · Hyderabad ● Other Md Qamaruddin Khan v Ahobilam Foods. 2026-juristway.com-3729-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST 18 November 2026 In Md Qamaruddin Khan v. Ahobilam Foods, 2026-juristway.com-3729-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST , where the Appellate Authority restored a registration cancelled for six months' default in GSTR-3B after noting that returns were filed and tax paid, and the Department sought restoration of the cancellation because interest, late fee and penalty were not secured, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench held that the Appellate Authority erred in not applying the proviso to Rule 23(1) (paras 10–10.2, 12). The Hon'ble Tribunal, however, read the appellate order as intending collection of the amounts in Rule 23, held that the Department was at liberty to recover interest and late fee under Sections 50 and 47 and ought to use Section 79 for admitted dues, and imposed a penalty of Rs. 10,000 (paras 11–11.2). The appellate order was modified to that extent, the taxpayer being unrepresented (paras 6, 12–14). SC ● Dismissed Joint Commissioner of Income Tax & Ors. v Ashok Kumar Manish Kumar Huf. 2026-juristway.com-3728-SC-IT 18 November 2026 In Joint Commissioner of Income Tax v. Ashok Kumar Manish Kumar HUF, 2026-juristway.com-3728-SC-IT , where the Revenue sought special leave against an order of the High Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court condoned the delay and, after hearing the Revenue and going through the record, found no good ground to interfere (paras 1–2). The special leave petition was dismissed (para 3). HC · Delhi ● Dismissed The Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax-3 v DLF Ltd. 2026-juristway.com-3727-HC(Delhi)-IT 18 November 2026 In Pr. CIT v. DLF Ltd., 2026-juristway.com-3727-HC(Delhi)-IT , where the Assessing Officer added Rs. 3,28,52,595 as notional rent on 23 commercial units, of which four were vacant throughout the year, and the Tribunal deleted the addition following its order for AY 2006-07, the Hon'ble Delhi High Court held that Section 23(1)(c) covered the case (para 13). The Hon'ble High Court agreed with Vivek Jain v. CIT on the conditions of Section 23(1)(c) (paras 10–11), and found from the assessee's affidavit that the four units had been let in earlier years and could not be let in the relevant year despite genuine efforts (paras 7, 13). Ansal Housing & Constructions Ltd. was distinguished as a case where the properties were never let (para 16). The other four questions were covered by the earlier judgment in ITA Nos. 926/2016 and 928/2016 (para 3). No substantial question of law arose and the appeal was dismissed (paras 17–18). HC · Delhi ● Allowed Parag Dalmia v Commissioner of Income Tax. Circle-1 & Anr., Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax. & Anr. 2026-juristway.com-3726-HC(Delhi)-IT 18 November 2026 In Parag Dalmia v. CIT, 2026-juristway.com-3726-HC(Delhi)-IT , where, in a search on 20.01.2012, a seven-page document on an alleged HSBC account in Switzerland, already held by the Revenue, was shown to the assessee, the search itself yielded only jewellery, and an addition of Rs. 1,20,37,863 was made under Section 153A, the Hon'ble Delhi High Court held that Section 153A could not be invoked on such a document (paras 14–15). Reading the section otherwise would give the Revenue unbridled power; reopening under other provisions remains available. Applying Abhisar Buildwell and Kabul Chawla, the Hon'ble High Court held that the Tribunal erred in its order dated 26.02.2018 in remanding the matter for verification of the document, and rejected the plea that those decisions came later, since Kabul Chawla predated the remand and declarations of law operate retrospectively (paras 18–19). The assessee's offer to pay tax, retracted after nine months, did not assist the Revenue once the notice was bad (para 20). Both appeals were allowed and the remand and all consequent orders set aside (paras 21–22). HC · Delhi ● Dismissed Commissioner of Income Tax, International Taxation-1, New Delhi v Emerging India Focus Funds. 2026-juristway.com-3725-HC(Delhi)-IT 18 November 2026 In CIT (International Taxation) v. Emerging India Focus Funds, 2026-juristway.com-3725-HC(Delhi)-IT , where a Mauritius-resident foreign institutional investor claimed capital gains of Rs. 5,93,48,24,274 on sale of units of equity-oriented mutual funds as exempt, and the Assessing Officer and the Dispute Resolution Panel taxed the gains under Article 13(3A) by looking through to the underlying equity shares, the Hon'ble Delhi High Court held that a unit holder is not a shareholder of any company and that the gains fall under Article 13(4) (para 17). The Hon'ble High Court relied on the definitions of “securities”, “mutual fund” and “unit”, on the separate mention of equity shares and units of equity-oriented funds in Section 10(38), and on Apollo Tyres Ltd., where units of UTI were held not to be deemed shares (paras 11–19). Treaty provisions allocating taxing rights are to be read strictly, and the plea of purposive interpretation was rejected (paras 20–21). The question was answered for the assessee and the appeal dismissed (paras 22–23). HC · Delhi ● Dismissed Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central, Gurugram v M/s. Experion Developers Pvt. Ltd. 2026-juristway.com-3724-HC(Delhi)-IT 18 November 2026 In Pr. CIT v. Experion Developers Pvt. Ltd., 2026-juristway.com-3724-HC(Delhi)-IT , where the Assessing Officer disallowed 90% of a developer's revenue expenditure on the footing that it should be capitalised as work-in-progress since no project revenue was recognised, and the Tribunal deleted the disallowance, the Hon'ble Delhi High Court held that the proposed questions were primarily questions of fact (para 22). The Tribunal had considered the accounting method, the allocation of expenditure to inventory, the business purpose and the accounting guidance, and had found the ad hoc disallowance arbitrary; that conclusion was not perverse (para 23). The Hon'ble High Court accepted that partial allowance by the Assessing Officer is not a conclusive admission and that consistency cannot override the Act, but noted that the Tribunal had also relied on findings on the nature and allocation of the expenditure (paras 24–25). No substantial question of law arose and the appeal was dismissed (paras 27–28). ITAT · Delhi ● Allowed Sabre GLBL Inc. v Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 3 (1) (2), International Taxation, Delhi 2026-juristway.com-3723-ITAT(Delhi)-IT 18 November 2026 In Sabre GLBL Inc. v. ACIT (International Taxation), 2026-juristway.com-3723-ITAT(Delhi)-IT , where a US company providing reservation and booking solutions to airlines and hotels claimed its Indian receipts of Rs. 59,25,92,157 as not taxable, and the Assessing Officer, on directions of the Dispute Resolution Panel, taxed them as fees for technical or included services, the Hon'ble Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench followed the coordinate Bench decision dated 07.01.2026 in Sabre Marketing Nederland, a group company, on facts stated to be identical (paras 3–4). That decision held that no right to use intellectual property, secret process or industrial, commercial or scientific experience is given to customers. Grounds 1 to 7 were decided for the assessee, and the result was applied to AY 2021-22 and AY 2022-23 (paras 4–4.1). HC · Karnataka ● Allowed The Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Audit), The Joint Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Appels), Bengaluru and The Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Belagavi, State of Karnataka Finance Department, Vidhana Soudha v M/s. Shree Renuka Sugars Ltd. and The Karnataka State Beverages Corporation Ltd. and The Executive Director (O) The Karnataka State Beverages Corporation Ltd and Karnataka Appellate Tribunal, Bengaluru 2026-juristway.com-3722-HC(Karnataka)-VAT/CST 18 November 2026 In Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Audit) v. Shree Renuka Sugars Ltd., 2026-juristway.com-3722-HC(Karnataka)-VAT/CST , where a Single Judge, in the manufacturer's writ petition challenging invocation of an indemnity bond by the State beverages corporation, held the Revenue's demand on export of denatured ethanol unsustainable and directed the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal to allow the corporation's pending second appeal, the Hon'ble Karnataka High Court held that the tax liability, already the subject of statutory proceedings, ought not to have been entertained (paras 32–34, 40). The Single Judge had also not addressed the principal question whether Form H was necessary for the claim of deemed export (paras 39–42). The orders dated 21.10.2024 and 04.09.2025 and the consequential order of the Tribunal dated 12.09.2025 were set aside. The writ petition was remanded to the Single Judge on the inter se dispute, including whether it should be entertained under Article 226, and the second appeal was restored to the Tribunal for fresh decision without any opinion on merits (paras 45–49). SC ● Allowed M/s Marino Dredgeco Limited v The Board of Trustees of The Port of Kolkata 2026-juristway.com-3721-SC-INDLAW 18 November 2026 In Marino Dredgeco Limited v. Board of Trustees of the Port of Kolkata, 2026-juristway.com-3721-SC-INDLAW , where the Division Bench, though finding the award for additional dredging work to be based on evidence, reduced it to 50% with interest at 6% because the claim exceeded 70% of the original contract value and shocked its conscience, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that such modification is outside Section 37 and is not a conflict with the most basic notions of morality or justice (para 8). The Hon'ble Supreme Court reasoned that the expression cannot be applied as lip service without a substantive reason, following Ssangyong Engineering and Somdatt Builders (paras 9–10); that an award quantified on measurements and invoices of one character cannot be severed into valid and invalid parts under Gayatri Balasamy (paras 11–12); and that a Government entity gets no special treatment, following Pam Developments (para 13). The impugned judgment was set aside and the award restored; the Port Trust's appeal was disposed of (paras 15–16). NCLAT · New Delhi-[PB] ● Dismissed M/s Radiant Inn Private Limited (Formerly Chaitanya Institute of Medical Sciences Private Limited) and Mrs. Suhani Deepak Bharadwaj v Registrar of Companies, Mumbai 2026-juristway.com-3680-NCLAT(New Delhi-[PB])-CORP 18 November 2026 In Radiant Inn Pvt. Ltd. v. Registrar of Companies, Mumbai, 2026-juristway.com-3680-NCLAT(New Delhi-[PB])-CORP , where a company holding an MIDC leasehold plot sought restoration but undertook not to recommence business, the Hon'ble National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi held that accounts, returns and a bank account with nil revenue did not show operation (paras 14–15). Restoration restores corporate status, not a mechanism for directors to deal with an asset, and no creditor or authority sought it (paras 16–21). The appeal was dismissed, clarifying that the NCLT's observations on fulfilment of lease conditions are not findings on the lease (paras 22–24). HC · Bombay ● Quashed Sachin Sawant v The Union of India and Anr. 2026-juristway.com-3679-HC(Bombay)-PMLA 18 November 2026 In Sachin Sawant v. Union of India, 2026-juristway.com-3679-HC(Bombay)-PMLA , where the Special Court took cognizance on 31.08.2023 of an ED complaint against a Joint Commissioner of Customs without any sanction, the Hon'ble Bombay High Court held that, following the Supreme Court's decision on Section 197 in PMLA cases, sanction was mandatory as the allegations concerned wealth amassed while discharging duty, and the defect went to jurisdiction (paras 12–17). The cognizance order was quashed (paras 18–20). HC · Bombay ● Quashed Chanda Kochhar v Central Bureau of Investigation and Anr. 2026-juristway.com-3678-HC(Bombay)-INDLAW 18 November 2026 In Chanda Kochhar v. CBI, 2026-juristway.com-3678-HC(Bombay)-INDLAW , where ICICI Bank's board sanctioned prosecution of its former MD over loans to the Videocon group, the Hon'ble Bombay High Court held that the challenge could be raised before charge under Section 19(4) and was not barred by Section 19(3) (paras 10–12). Since Sections 5A, 35B and 36AA of the Banking Regulation Act override the articles, the board could not remove the MD and so could not sanction (paras 15–28, 45). Only the CBI's letter and report were before the board, showing no application of mind (Ameerjan), and a void sanction cannot await trial (Nanjappa) (paras 29–44). The sanction dated 15.05.2023 was quashed, and a stay was refused (paras 47–49). HC · Himachal Pradesh ● Allowed M/s. Rama Krishna Industries v State of Himachal Pradesh and Others 2026-juristway.com-3720-HC(Himachal Pradesh)-GST 17 November 2026 In Rama Krishna Industries v. State of Himachal Pradesh, 2026-juristway.com-3720-HC(Himachal Pradesh)-GST , where a show cause notice dated 22.08.2026 was issued under Section 74 and the State objected that a writ against a notice was not maintainable, the Hon'ble Himachal Pradesh High Court held that the statutory requirement must be correlated with the allegations in the notice, and that reciting allegations followed by a bald assertion of fraud or suppression is insufficient (paras 8–9). Applying Tata Steel Limited and G.R. Infra Projects Limited, the Hon'ble High Court found that the notice neither alleged nor established fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression, and quashed it (paras 10–13). On the State's request for liberty to issue a fresh notice, opposed on limitation, the Hon'ble High Court only observed that the judgment would not prevent the authority from proceeding as per law, subject to all just exceptions (paras 14–15). HC · Allahabad ● Allowed Bachcha Nand Singh v State of U.P. and 2 Others 2026-juristway.com-3719-HC(Allahabad)-GST 17 November 2026 In Bachcha Nand Singh v. State of U.P., 2026-juristway.com-3719-HC(Allahabad)-GST , where an appeal against cancellation of registration was rejected as beyond the condonable period under Section 107 despite an affidavit pleading illness, the Hon'ble Allahabad High Court set aside the appellate order dated 28.09.2026 and condoned the delay subject to deposit of Rs. 10,000 by 04.12.2026 (para 9). A date is to be fixed in the third week of December 2026 and the appeal decided within two months thereafter. The order was passed on consent without adjudicating the merits, and its benefit lapses if the deposit is not made in time (paras 11–12). HC · Allahabad ● Remanded M/s Thermal Erectors & Construction Co. v State of U.P. and 2 Others 2026-juristway.com-3718-HC(Allahabad)-GST 17 November 2026 In Thermal Erectors & Construction Co. v. State of U.P., 2026-juristway.com-3718-HC(Allahabad)-GST , where a show cause notice dated 21.11.2024 under Section 73 fixed 21.12.2024 for reply but 04.12.2024 for personal hearing, and the taxpayer's appeal against the resulting order was rejected for delay, the Hon'ble Allahabad High Court held that no personal hearing can be held before the time for reply lapses and that the order was passed in violation of natural justice (para 8). The Standing Counsel agreed to a remand to cure the irregularity (para 6). The order dated 11.02.2025 and the appellate order dated 02.06.2026 were set aside and the matter was remitted for a fresh order (para 9). SC ● Dismissed Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax v SVP Industries Limited. 2026-juristway.com-3717-SC-IT 17 November 2026 In Pr. CIT v. SVP Industries Limited, 2026-juristway.com-3717-SC-IT , where the Revenue sought special leave against the impugned orders, the Hon'ble Supreme Court condoned the delay and declined to interfere under Article 136 (paras 1–2). The special leave petitions were dismissed and pending applications disposed of (para 3). ITAT · Delhi ● Allowed Bina Modi (Legal Representative of Late Shri Krishan Kumar Modi) v Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle 26, New Delhi 2026-juristway.com-3716-ITAT(Delhi)-IT 17 November 2026 In Bina Modi (LR of Late Shri Krishan Kumar Modi) v. ACIT, 2026-juristway.com-3716-ITAT(Delhi)-IT , where, after a first penalty order dated 30.06.2015, the Assessing Officer levied a second penalty on Rs. 5,81,32,321 surrendered in respect of an alleged foreign bank account, on a direction in the first appellate order dated 27.03.2017, the Hon'ble Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench deleted the penalty, deciding five issues for the assessee. Undisclosed income: The bank document was not seized in the search but carried by the Revenue; income so noticed is outside Section 271AAA (para 15). Second penalty order: The Assessing Officer was functus officio after the first penalty order, and had made no addition of this amount (para 16). Protective retention and direction: No penalty survives on a protective addition, and the appellate authority cannot direct what the Assessing Officer himself could not do (paras 17–18). Immunity and death: The surrender with tax paid satisfied Section 271AAA(2); the coordinate Bench order in the assessee's own case, noting the assessee's death, was followed (paras 19–20). Notice: A notice that specified neither the addition nor the charge cannot support the penalty (paras 21–22). Order: Penalty of Rs. 59,87,723 deleted (para 23). Load more