Case Law
43,513 judgments · newest first · showing 25
M/s Fatehpur Foundry & Engineering Works-vs-Arvind Kumar, Additional Commissioner, Prayagraj-2026-juristway.com-3639-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST
Alt+← → switch · Alt+W close · right-click for options
2026-juristway.com-3639-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GSTM/s Fatehpur Foundry v Arvind Kumar
✓ Good LawDismissed2 Judge Bench
TreatmentNot yet cited by a later judgment
2026-juristway.com-3639-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST

M/s Fatehpur Foundry & Engineering Works

versus

Arvind Kumar, Additional Commissioner, Prayagraj

Court - Bench
GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) - Prayagraj
Date of Judgment
17 November 2026
Judges
Mr. Mahtab Ahmad, Member (Judicial), Mr. Ashish Varma, Member (Technical)
Case Number
APL/22/ALB/2026
Advocate (Petitioner)
Satyarth Agrawal, Sanjeev Agrawal, Deepika Bedi Agrawal
Advocate (Respondent)
Smt Vibha Mishra Dcst/sr, Shri Suneel Kumar Nirmal Acst/asr
Quick ref
Takeaway

FY 2018-19 (June 2018) | Demand of Rs. 4,16,849.40 (ITC of Rs. 1,40,827.50) upheld | Taxpayer's appeal dismissed

Fabricated Transport Documents — ITC Denied Under Section 74

Invoices, e-way bills, banking payments and the supplier's returns do not establish receipt of goods under Section 16(2)(b) where the transport documents produced are shown to be fabricated. A notice that substantively alleges collusion and sham invoices satisfies Section 74 even without the words "fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression", by virtue of Section 160.

Digest & Analysis
Litigation Digest

In Fatehpur Foundry & Engineering Works v. Additional Commissioner, Prayagraj, 2026-juristway.com-3639-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST, where ITC on two June 2018 purchases of Rs. 7,82,375 from a supplier later found non-existent was reversed under Section 74, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Prayagraj Bench dismissed the appeal, deciding two issues.

Genuineness of purchases: The goods receipts first produced in appeal, without leave to adduce additional evidence, had glaring defects, including a consignor's copy and an altered number; this rendered the weighbridge slips and other documents mere showpiece paperwork, and the transactions were held not genuine (paras 7.1.6–7.1.11, 7.1.20).

Section 74: Though the notice did not use the statutory words, it alleged bogus invoices and collusion to evade tax, which in substance met Section 74; Section 160 saved it (paras 7.2.4–7.2.8).

Order: The order-in-original and order-in-appeal were confirmed (Order).

✎ Editor's Note

Practice point: Transport documents, weighbridge slips and toll receipts should be produced before the proper officer, not first in the second appeal; documents surfacing late will be scrutinised closely and, if defective, can sink the entire claim. Where new evidence is essential, file a formal application for additional evidence.

Risk: The Allahabad High Court rulings on later-cancelled suppliers were distinguished on the finding of fabricated GRs; they remain available where the movement evidence is genuine.

Note on the text: The Tribunal records that the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Bhandari Scrap Traders v. Union of India (SLP (C) No. 23931 of 2026) held tax deposit by the supplier to be a condition precedent for ITC; that order should be checked before it is cited.

Disclaimer: This content reflects the editor's personal views and should not be treated as a legal opinion or professional advice.

Full Text
Judgment & Order
14px