Case Law
43,469 judgments · newest first · showing 25
M/s. Grace Book Centre-vs-Commissioner Concerned Uttar Pradesh Lucknow, Commissioner, State GST Office UP. & Ors.-2026-juristway.com-3596-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST
Alt+← → switch · Alt+W close · right-click for options
2026-juristway.com-3596-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GSTM/s. Grace Book Centre v Commissioner Concerned Uttar Pradesh Lucknow
✓ Good LawAllowed2 Judge Bench
TreatmentNot yet cited by a later judgment
2026-juristway.com-3596-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST

M/s. Grace Book Centre

versus

Commissioner Concerned Uttar Pradesh Lucknow, Commissioner, State GST Office UP. & Ors.

Court - Bench
GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) - Prayagraj
Date of Judgment
16 November 2026
Judges
Mr. Mahtab Ahmad, Member (Judicial), Mr. Ashish Varma, Member (Technical)
Case Number
APL/80/ALB/2026
Advocate (Petitioner)
Arun Kumar Kushwaha - Adv. Anurag Singh - Adv.
Advocate (Respondent)
Smt. Vibha Mishra, DC/Sr Shri Suneel Kumar Nirmal, AC/ASR
Quick ref
Takeaway

FY 2017-18 | Demand of Rs. 3,10,289.76 (tax, interest and penalty) set aside | Taxpayer's appeal allowed

Survey Inferences Alone — No Section 74

A Section 74 notice must disclose the foundational facts of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression with intent to evade; inferences drawn by stock phrases from a one-day survey do not suffice. A demand on a uniform monthly turnover with no basis in the survey or returns, ignoring exempt supplies, cannot be sustained, and Section 75(2) does not arise where no tax is shown payable.

Digest & Analysis
Litigation Digest

In Grace Book Centre v. Commissioner, State GST, 2026-juristway.com-3596-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST, where a Prayagraj bookseller was assessed ex parte under Section 74 for FY 2017-18 on a survey of 31.03.2018 and a demand computed on identical monthly turnovers of Rs. 1,67,000, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Prayagraj Bench set aside the demand, deciding four questions for the taxpayer.

Section 74: Following Tata Steel, Continental Foundation and Audi Automobiles, the notice stated only "Suppression of fact, Misstatement" and four survey-based inferences, with no fact showing tax was withheld; non-attendance on summons and later silence cannot supply foundational facts (paras 10–14).

Quantification: One day's sale on the eve of the academic session cannot be extrapolated, the stock was never reconciled, and tax of Rs. 1,17,360 on an "evaded" turnover of Rs. 1,30,200 is 90.14%, beyond the 40% ceiling under Section 9; over 82% of the declared turnover of Rs. 36,98,572.75 was exempt printed books (paras 15–20).

Orders below: Service by e-mail and the portal was valid, but the OIO did not meet Sections 74(9) and 75(6), and the OIA, which quoted the words of Section 73(1) as Section 74(1), breached Section 107(12) (paras 21–22).

Consequences: Remand was declined as the defects lay at the root, and Section 75(2) does not operate where no tax is shown payable (paras 23–25).

Order: The demand of Rs. 3,10,289.76 was dropped and the pre-deposits of Rs. 14,670 and Rs. 11,736 ordered to be refunded with interest (para 27).

✎ Editor's Note

Practice point: Against Section 74 demands founded on surveys, compare the DRC-01 summary and notice with Tata Steel: a summary reciting only "suppression" and inferences framed as "it is clear that" is open to challenge. Test the arithmetic of the demand against the statutory rate ceiling and the exempt share of turnover; that analysis was decisive here.

Practice point: Appellants who miss hearings before the first appellate authority can still press Section 107(12); an ex parte appeal must be decided on its grounds with reasons.

Open question: The first appeal was filed on 31.01.2024 against an order communicated on 19.07.2021. The order does not record how that delay was dealt with, and the Revenue did not raise it.

Disclaimer: This content reflects the editor's personal views and should not be treated as a legal opinion or professional advice.

Full Text
Judgment & Order
14px