GSTAT · Prayagraj ● Allowed M/s. Grace Book Centre v Commissioner Concerned Uttar Pradesh Lucknow, Commissioner, State GST Office UP. & Ors. 2026-juristway.com-3596-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST 16 November 2026 In Grace Book Centre v. Commissioner, State GST, 2026-juristway.com-3596-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST , where a Prayagraj bookseller was assessed ex parte under Section 74 for FY 2017-18 on a survey of 31.03.2018 and a demand computed on identical monthly turnovers of Rs. 1,67,000, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Prayagraj Bench set aside the demand, deciding four questions for the taxpayer. Section 74: Following Tata Steel, Continental Foundation and Audi Automobiles, the notice stated only "Suppression of fact, Misstatement" and four survey-based inferences, with no fact showing tax was withheld; non-attendance on summons and later silence cannot supply foundational facts (paras 10–14). Quantification: One day's sale on the eve of the academic session cannot be extrapolated, the stock was never reconciled, and tax of Rs. 1,17,360 on an "evaded" turnover of Rs. 1,30,200 is 90.14%, beyond the 40% ceiling under Section 9; over 82% of the declared turnover of Rs. 36,98,572.75 was exempt printed books (paras 15–20). Orders below: Service by e-mail and the portal was valid, but the OIO did not meet Sections 74(9) and 75(6), and the OIA, which quoted the words of Section 73(1) as Section 74(1), breached Section 107(12) (paras 21–22). Consequences: Remand was declined as the defects lay at the root, and Section 75(2) does not operate where no tax is shown payable (paras 23–25). Order: The demand of Rs. 3,10,289.76 was dropped and the pre-deposits of Rs. 14,670 and Rs. 11,736 ordered to be refunded with interest (para 27). GSTAT · Ernakulam ● Dismissed Popular Industries v The Commissioner of CGST, Kochi 2026-juristway.com-3595-GSTAT(Ernakulam)-GST 13 November 2026 In Popular Industries v. Commissioner of CGST, 2026-juristway.com-3595-GSTAT(Ernakulam)-GST , where a candle exporter was sanctioned a refund of Rs. 6,16,479 for February–March 2018 and the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) found an excess of Rs. 67,993 by excluding Rs. 1,58,760 reversed in February 2018 from Net ITC, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench upheld the appellate order. Table 4(C) of the GSTR-3B returns showed Net ITC of Rs. 12,11,181 for the two months, which, less the undisputed ineligible credit of Rs. 8,057, gave an eligible refund of Rs. 5,48,486 under Rule 89(4) (paras 4.3–4.8). The plea that the reversal related to a September 2017 refund and was being deducted twice was rejected for want of any DRC-03 or other proof, and the reduction of a refund claim and a debit in the credit ledger were held to be different events (paras 4.6, 4.11–4.12). The Hon'ble Tribunal also observed that the appellant had not approached it with clean hands (para 4.11). GSTAT · Ernakulam ● Allowed Super Teck Industries v The Commissioner of State GST, Thiruvananthapuram. 2026-juristway.com-3594-GSTAT(Ernakulam)-GST 13 November 2026 In Super Teck Industries v. Commissioner of State GST, 2026-juristway.com-3594-GSTAT(Ernakulam)-GST , where a consignment of 200 open well pumps from Coimbatore to Crompton Greaves Consumer Electronics, Kochi was intercepted on 11.02.2021 at Walayar with a tax invoice and valid e-way bill but without an e-invoice, which was generated the next day, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench set aside the penalty, deciding two issues for the taxpayer. Jurisdiction: The MOV-07 and MOV-09 were issued to a Tamil Nadu registrant without a Kerala temporary ID, which was generated only for the DRC-07 on 28.06.2021, so the notices and order were without jurisdiction (paras 6.0, 8.1). E-invoice: The physical verification found no discrepancy and the tax was reported in the returns. Circular No. 160/16/2021-GST requires no physical carriage of the e-invoice, the Act prescribes no time limit for it, and the obligation under Section 31 and Rules 46 and 48 rests on the supplier; following Osel Devices and Nancy Trading Company, Section 129 cannot be invoked for a missing e-invoice where a proper tax invoice exists (paras 7.1–7.13, 8.2). Order: The MOV-07 and MOV-09 were declared void and the order-in-appeal dated 30.12.2021 set aside with consequential relief. HC · Calcutta ● Dismissed Assistant Commissioner of Central Excise, Haldia-II Division v Haldia Petro Chemicals Limited & Ors. 2026-juristway.com-3593-HC(Calcutta)-CE 13 November 2026 In Assistant Commissioner of Central Excise v. Haldia Petro Chemicals Ltd., 2026-juristway.com-3593-HC(Calcutta)-CE , where the Revisional Authority remanded a rebate claim of Rs. 2,25,66,522 on three shipments of pyrolysis gasoline exported in 2003 for production of further documents, and a Single Judge set aside the remand, the Hon'ble Calcutta High Court dismissed the Department's appeal. The pre-conditions for rebate are payment of duty and export; the procedure in Paragraph 8 of the Supplementary Instructions, 2005 is directory, as held in UM Cables following Mangalore Chemicals (paras 8–10). The ARE-1 forms were certified by both Excise and Customs, accompanied by bank certificates and original shipping bills, and never questioned, so the Revenue could not travel beyond the show cause notice on a vague plea of missing documents (paras 11–12). The claim, pending since 2004, was to be paid (paras 13–14). GSTAT · Thiruvananthapuram ● Allowed Tasty Nut Industries v The Commissioner of Keralam State GST Thiruvananthapuram 2026-juristway.com-3562-GSTAT(Thiruvananthapuram)-GST 13 November 2026 In Tasty Nut Industries v. Commissioner of Keralam State GST, 2026-juristway.com-3562-GSTAT(Thiruvananthapuram)-GST , where cashew kernels worth Rs. 21,34,254 were stock-transferred from the Tamil Nadu unit to the Kerala unit with an invoice and e-way bill but no e-invoice, and a penalty equal to IGST was imposed, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram Bench held the movement to be an inter-State supply between distinct persons (para 4.5). There was no discrepancy in goods or documents, IGST was reported in GSTR-1 and GSTR-2B, and Circular No. 160/16/2021-GST does not require the e-invoice to be carried (paras 4.4–4.7). Following Osel Devices and Nancy Trading, the penalty was set aside (paras 4.14–5.0). GSTAT · Lucknow ● Allowed Manoj Traders v Sanjay Kumar Pathak, Additional Commissioner Grade-II, U.P 2026-juristway.com-3561-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST 13 November 2026 In Manoj Traders v. Commissioner of State Tax, U.P., 2026-juristway.com-3561-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST , where a kirana trader's first appeal left a 5% tax and penalty on Rs. 4,46,323 recorded in three loose slips seized in a 2018 survey, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Lucknow Bench found that the slips covered exempt loose atta and maida and goods billed on 23.04.2018 under invoices reported in April 2018 returns (paras 6.1.1–6.2.3). The Department could not verify the B2C data on the portal (para 6.2.1). The residual demand was set aside and any amount paid is to be refunded (Order). CESTAT · Mumbai ● Allowed Fortune Gourmet Specialities Pvt Ltd v Commissioner of Customs, Nhava Sheva, Raigad 2026-juristway.com-3560-CESTAT(Mumbai)-Customs 13 November 2026 In Fortune Gourmet Specialities Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs, Nhava Sheva, 2026-juristway.com-3560-CESTAT(Mumbai)-Customs , where Starbucks Frappuccino imported in three flavours was assessed under CTH 2202 99 90 with IGST at 28% as a caffeinated beverage, the Hon'ble Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, Mumbai Bench compared FSSAI categories and found that the product is a dairy-based drink without synthetic caffeine or energy-drink labelling (paras 4.6, 4.9). The lower orders ignored the tariff headings and explanatory notes (para 4.7). Applying Hamdard (Waqf) Laboratories and Dunlop India, the specific entry 2202 99 30 prevails over the residuary entry, taking the goods outside Sl. No. 12A (paras 4.8–4.10). The appeal was allowed (para 5.1). CESTAT · Kolkata ● Partly Allowed M/s. Manish Kumar Singh v Commissioner of C.G.S.T. and Central Excise, Rourkela 2026-juristway.com-3559-CESTAT(Kolkata)-ST 13 November 2026 In Manish Kumar Singh v. Commissioner of CGST & CE, Rourkela, 2026-juristway.com-3559-CESTAT(Kolkata)-ST , where a coal and iron transporter was taxed on ITR receipts for 2016-17 for not producing all documents during the pandemic, the Hon'ble Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, Kolkata Bench admitted work orders, challans and ledgers showing no consignment notes were issued (paras 12–13.4.5). Following Tabassum Enterprises, the service was exempt (paras 13.6–14). The demand rested only on ITR figures, following Quest Engineers (paras 15–15.4). The extended period failed since the data came from returns (paras 16–17). The demand and penalties under Sections 77(1)(c)(ii) and 78 were set aside, but the Section 77(2) penalty was upheld (paras 18–19). CESTAT · Kolkata ● Allowed M/s. Nuance Group (India) Private Limited v Commissioner of Customs (Airport & A.C.C.), Kolkata 2026-juristway.com-3558-CESTAT(Kolkata)-Customs 13 November 2026 In Nuance Group (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs (Airport & A.C.C.), Kolkata, 2026-juristway.com-3558-CESTAT(Kolkata)-Customs , where a duty-free operator's application for a special warehouse licence was rejected because of penalties imposed in 2017 under Sections 112 and 114 and their non-disclosure, the Hon'ble Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, Kolkata Bench held that Chapter XIV penalties are distinct from Chapter XVI offences (paras 14–14.2). Following Kundan Care Products, Mumbai Travel Retail and Hari Krishna Exports, it held that past penalties cannot bar a licence (paras 14.3–15). Bhagwati Products, which applied Maqbool Hussain, was held erroneous and distinguished (paras 16–18). The applicant held a 2023 Bengaluru licence and AEO status (paras 20–23). The order was set aside and the licence directed by 15.11.2026 (paras 24–26). GSTAT · Cuttack ● Dismissed Ram Niwas Agarwal v Dhirendra Kumar Parida, Addl. Commissioner of State Tax (Appeal) 2026-juristway.com-3444-GSTAT(Cuttack)-GST 13 November 2026 In Ram Niwas Agarwal v. Dhirendra Kumar Parida, 2026-juristway.com-3444-GSTAT(Cuttack)-GST , where a steel manufacturer availed ITC of Rs. 1,07,712 in September 2020 on two invoices of M/s Lakra Steel, whose named proprietor disowned the business and whose rent agreement was signed in the names of persons long dead, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Cuttack Bench held that no supply can exist without an existing supplier, so the invoices were mere paper transactions (paras 10, 13). Invoices, e-way bills, weighment slips and payment by bearer cheques did not prove receipt of goods; the stock register and affidavit filed for the first time could not be admitted without a formal application for additional evidence (paras 11, 15). On Quest Merchandising and Gargo Traders were distinguished because the supplier's genuineness was not in doubt there (paras 16–18). The Hon'ble Tribunal held Section 74 rightly invoked and found no breach of natural justice; the appeal was dismissed (paras 19–21). GSTAT · Bengaluru ● Allowed Pallawi Anand v Sadhana Enviro Engineering Services, Bangalore 2026-juristway.com-3592-GSTAT(Bengaluru)-GST 12 November 2026 In Pallawi Anand v. SADHANA Enviro Engineering Services, 2026-juristway.com-3592-GSTAT(Bengaluru)-GST , where the Commissioner (Appeals) dropped the penalty on Rs. 34,69,134 short-paid in GSTR-3B and converted a demand of Rs. 19,02,658 on P&L write-offs and Form 26AS receipts from Section 74 to Section 73, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Bengaluru Bench allowed the Department's appeal, deciding six issues against the taxpayer. Bench: As only penalties survived, the appeal belonged to the bench assigned "Order imposing penalty" under Office Order No. 4/GSTAT/PB/2026 (para 6.1). DIN: A review authorisation under Section 112(3) is an internal departmental direction, so the DIN requirement in Circular No. 122/41/2019-GST and Pradeep Goyal does not apply (paras 6.2–6.4). Section 128A: The SPL-05 order covered only the Rs. 40,000 Section 73 penalty and cannot bar a Revenue appeal already filed on other penalties (para 6.5). Hearing: The record showed personal hearings on 24.11.2023 and 30.11.2023, so Section 75(4) was complied with (paras 6.6–6.7). Section 74 on Rs. 19,02,658: Following Sriba Nirman Company, Mehta & Co. and Continental Foundation, receipts in the P&L but withheld from returns, and disclosed in GSTR-9 only after audit, are wilful suppression (paras 6.10–6.14). Penalty on Rs. 34,69,134: Section 74 did not apply to turnover declared in GSTR-1, but waiver under Sections 73(6)/73(8) read with Section 75(2) needs payment of interest, which was not made (para 6.15). Order: Penalties of Rs. 3,59,368 under Section 73 and Rs. 19,02,658 under Section 74 were confirmed (Order, para 2). HC · Telangana ● Allowed M/s. Tecumseh Products India Private Limited v Income Tax Officer, National Faceless Assessment Centre, Delhi. 2026-juristway.com-3591-HC(Telangana)-IT 12 November 2026 In Tecumseh Products India Pvt. Ltd. v. ITO, 2026-juristway.com-3591-HC(Telangana)-IT , where the AO, after a TPO order proposing an adjustment of Rs. 65,78,92,738, issued a show cause notice and then a final assessment order without a draft order, the Hon'ble Telangana High Court set aside the assessment. Section 144C(1) opens with a non-obstante clause and gives eligible assessees a substantive right to object before the DRP; following SHL (India), its breach is a jurisdictional defect that Section 292B cannot cure (paras 14–16, 21). A show cause notice under Section 144B does not carry the consequences of a draft order, and the impugned order was plainly final, being under Section 143(3), with a demand notice and a penalty direction; the portal offered only an appeal, and AY 2017-18 had followed the draft route (paras 17–20). Interglobe Enterprises supported the petitioner, as the alternative remedy yields to breach of mandatory procedure (paras 22–24). The order, demand notice and penalty direction were set aside, and the proceedings restored to the stage after the TPO's order (paras 26–27). HC · Karnataka ● Dismissed Sri. Erigala Ram Pula Reddy v M/s. Grind Stone Crusher LLP 2026-juristway.com-3590-HC(Karnataka)-INDLAW 12 November 2026 In Erigala Ram Pula Reddy v. Grind Stone Crusher LLP, 2026-juristway.com-3590-HC(Karnataka)-INDLAW , where the accused in a Section 138 complaint sought rejection of an MoU marked as Exhibit P1 for want of adequate stamp duty, the Hon'ble Karnataka High Court upheld the refusal. Section 33 governs examination and impounding, and clause (a) of its proviso gives a criminal court discretion not to impound; Section 34 governs admissibility, and clause (c) of its proviso leaves no discretion to exclude an instrument in criminal proceedings outside the named chapters (paras 21–28). The two provisions operate in different fields: if the document is impounded, duty and penalty may be recovered under Section 46, but payment is not a condition of admission (paras 31–34, 37). The Magistrate's reasons were not approved, but the order admitting the document was sustained (para 36). HC · Calcutta ● Remanded Kamdhenu Udyog Private Limited & Anr. v The Assistant Commissioner of Revenue, Office of The Charge Officer, Commercial Taxes, Bhabanipur Charge & Ors. 2026-juristway.com-3557-HC(Calcutta)-GST 12 November 2026 In Kamdhenu Udyog Pvt. Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of Revenue, Bhabanipur Charge, 2026-juristway.com-3557-HC(Calcutta)-GST , where a Section 73 order for 2018-19 went unanswered and the appeal was dismissed as delayed because the tax consultant fell seriously ill, the Hon'ble Calcutta High Court followed Ram Kumar Sinhal and GSPR Developers (paras 8, 14). Despite the State's objection that hearings were offered, the dismissal was quashed, and the appeal is to be decided on merits within six weeks after hearing (paras 12–13). HC · Punjab & Haryana ● Bail Granted Amit Bhasin v Central Goods and Service Tax Commissionerate, Gurugram. 2026-juristway.com-3556-HC(Punjab & Haryana)-GST 12 November 2026 In Amit Bhasin v. CGST Commissionerate, Gurugram, 2026-juristway.com-3556-HC(Punjab & Haryana)-GST , where a director of the GoMechanic brand company was arrested over fake ITC passed through 28 shell firms, and argued that the reasons for arrest were recorded by an Inspector instead of the Commissioner under Radhika Agarwal, the Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court granted bail (paras 4–10). The complaint was filed on 22.09.2026 and the co-accused had been released after his arrest was held illegal (para 9). The Instruction reflects a later policy against arrests (para 9). The legality of the arrest itself was not decided. HC · Punjab & Haryana ● Other Parmod Kumar and Another v Union of India and Others 2026-juristway.com-3555-HC(Punjab & Haryana)-GST 12 November 2026 In Parmod Kumar v. Union of India, 2026-juristway.com-3555-HC(Punjab & Haryana)-GST , where the petitioners sought anticipatory bail after an Order-in-Original of the CGST Ludhiana Joint Commissioner, the Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court took on record Instruction No. 02/2026-GST, issued after the 57th GST Council meeting, and the Department accepted that it is binding (paras 3–4). The petition was disposed of with a direction not to arrest the petitioners while the Instruction operates, with liberty to return if it is withdrawn or breached (paras 5–7). HC · Calcutta ● Remanded Keshab Joshi v The State of West Bengal & Ors. 2026-juristway.com-3554-HC(Calcutta)-GST 12 November 2026 In Keshab Joshi v. State of West Bengal, 2026-juristway.com-3554-HC(Calcutta)-GST , where an ex parte order for 2020-21 was followed by an appeal dismissed on limitation, bank attachment and ECL recoveries of Rs. 3,59,409 and Rs. 1,04,574 despite the 10% pre-deposit, the Hon'ble Calcutta High Court held that the petitioner could not be left remediless (para 11). The appellate order of 21.11.2025 was quashed, and the appellate authority was directed to decide the appeal on merits within six weeks after hearing, considering the attachment and recoveries (paras 12–15). GSTAT · Lucknow ● Dismissed M/s Neptune Sales Corporation v AN Yadav, Addl. Comm. Gr-2 Appeal-II, State Tax Office Lucknow & Ors. 2026-juristway.com-3553-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST 12 November 2026 In Neptune Sales Corporation v. Commissioner of State Tax, U.P., 2026-juristway.com-3553-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST , where paper aluminium foil laminate moved from Kanpur Dehat to Lucknow on a manual invoice and the e-invoice and e-way bill were generated about 14 and 19 hours after interception at 04:03 AM, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Lucknow Bench held that the documents did not exist when verification began (para 7.6). The plea of portal problems was unsupported, and matching quantity, registered parties and branded goods did not help (paras 7.7–7.10). Following Jhansi Enterprises and Akhilesh Traders, Satyam Shivam Papers and Shyam Sel were distinguished (paras 7.13–7.20). The penalty was upheld (para 7.23 and Order). GSTAT · Lucknow ● Allowed Santosh Kumar Singh v M/s Agarwal Flexi Pack, Proprietor, UPKNN 2026-juristway.com-3552-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST 12 November 2026 In Santosh Kumar Singh v. Agrawal Flexipack, 2026-juristway.com-3552-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST , where a search on a Kanpur packaging manufacturer found excess adhesive, ink, film and finished rolls of Rs. 8,36,246 and the First Appellate Authority deleted the demand as based on eye estimation, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Lucknow Bench first held the appeal maintainable despite the monetary limit, since the Section 130 versus Section 73/74 question is recurring (paras 2–2.1). The panchnama recorded non-uniform weights such as 253 kg and 131 kg, and the accountant signed without demur, following Surjeet Singh Chhabra (paras 7.2–7.2.2). Girija Ispat and Fakir Chand Hajarimal were distinguished (para 7.3). The order-in-original was restored (para 7.6 and Order). GSTAT · Lucknow ● Dismissed Ajeet Kumar Singh v Sona Enterprises, Proprietor 2026-juristway.com-3551-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST 12 November 2026 In Ajeet Kumar Singh v. Sona Enterprises, 2026-juristway.com-3551-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST , where a Delhi supplier sent furniture to a Bodh Gaya hotel under Invoice Nos. 598 and 599 with a single e-way bill for Rs. 5,98,811, and the Mobile Squad levied tax and penalty, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Lucknow Bench held that the invoices, e-way bill and bilty accompanied the goods and no discrepancy in quantity or description was found (paras 6.6–6.8). The supply was reported in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B with IGST paid (para 6.7). Relying on Hindustan Herbal Cosmetics, Hindustan Steel and Circular No. 64/38/2018-GST, the Department's appeal was dismissed (paras 6.9–6.11). GSTAT · Chandigarh ● Allowed R.K. Enterprises v K.S. Chahal, Deputy Excise and Taxation Commissioner Patial. 2026-juristway.com-3550-GSTAT(Chandigarh)-GST 12 November 2026 In R.K. Enterprises v. Commissioner of State GST, Punjab, 2026-juristway.com-3550-GSTAT(Chandigarh)-GST , where aluminium scrap moving under invoice, e-way bill, GR and weighment slip was confiscated because the supplier had taken credit from non-paying firms, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench first corrected the cause title under Rule 33(1) of the GSTAT Procedure Rules (para 2). Neither the notice nor the order alleged any defect in the transit documents (paras 25–27). Suspected wrong credit on past purchases is not a ground under Section 130(1)(i) or (iv) without a nexus to the detained goods (paras 29–30). The confiscation and penalty were set aside with consequential relief (paras 31–33). HC · Punjab & Haryana ● Dismissed Vikas v National Faceless Assessment Centre. 2026-juristway.com-3549-HC(Punjab & Haryana)-IT 12 November 2026 In Vikas v. NFAC, 2026-juristway.com-3549-HC(Punjab & Haryana)-IT , where the assessee replied and sought a video-conference hearing well after the deadline of 01.03.2026 and after the ILDP was generated on 13.03.2026, the Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court held that Section 144B(1)(xiii) and 144B(6)(vii) require a timely reply or an extension application (paras 18–22). The ILDP marks the close of the show cause stage (para 20). Arihant Roller Flour Mills, Suvidhi Udyog and Champion Exim concerned timely requests left unattended (paras 23–24). A one-day gap between the order date and digital signature caused no prejudice (para 27). The petition was dismissed, leaving the appeal under Section 246A (paras 29–30). NCLT · Kochi ● Other In Re. : Aesthetic Gold Ornaments Private Limited, AL-Ahali Business Trade Links Private Limited, Blaze Gold Jewels Private Limited, Blossom Gold Collections Private Limited, Ecomate Packaging Private Limited, Emerald Gold Souk (India) Private Limited, Eminent Jewel Arcade Private Limited, Fort-in Infragold Collections Private Limited and Others 2026-juristway.com-3548-NCLT(Kochi)-CORP 12 November 2026 In In Re: Aesthetic Gold Ornaments Pvt. Ltd., 2026-juristway.com-3548-NCLT(Kochi)-CORP , where 51 Malabar Gold group companies sought amalgamation into Malabar Gold and Diamonds Ltd. after RBI and CCI approvals and 139 meetings, the Hon'ble National Company Law Tribunal, Kochi Bench considered objections from the Income Tax Department (post-search undisclosed income of Rs. 844,49,96,888), GST and Customs authorities, EPFO, ESIC, the Regional Director and the Official Liquidator (paras 70–93). It directed the transferee to discharge all statutory dues as determined, kept authorities free to proceed, and preserved liability of officers in default (paras 81–93, 97–100). Finding the scheme fair and not contrary to public policy, the Hon'ble Tribunal sanctioned it with the appointed date of 01.04.2025 (paras 94–96, 107). GSTAT · Chandigarh ● Dismissed Harinder Pal Singh v Prasanna Enterprises 2026-juristway.com-3443-GSTAT(Chandigarh)-GST 12 November 2026 In Commissioner of CGST, Chandigarh v. Prasanna Enterprises, 2026-juristway.com-3443-GSTAT(Chandigarh)-GST , where refund of Rs. 7,98,271 for July 2022 was challenged because the shipping bill (12.08.2022) and EGM (20.08.2022) fell in August, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench applied Shruti Bansal v. Solitaire Pharmacia and held that the time of supply of export goods is the issue of invoice on removal, so the July invoice was rightly included in zero-rated turnover, export being undisputed (paras 9–12). The cause title was corrected under Rule 33(2) to name the Commissioner, and the Department's appeal was rejected (paras 2, 13). GSTAT · Chandigarh ● Dismissed Harinder Pal Singh v Prasanna Enterprises 2026-juristway.com-3442-GSTAT(Chandigarh)-GST 12 November 2026 In Commissioner of CGST, Chandigarh v. Prasanna Enterprises, 2026-juristway.com-3442-GSTAT(Chandigarh)-GST , where the Department sought to exclude a shipping bill dated 20.01.2022 of FOB value Rs. 46,78,200 from zero-rated turnover because the EGM date was 25.04.2022, alleging excess refund of Rs. 1,62,924, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench followed its decision in Shruti Bansal v. Solitaire Pharmacia (paras 11–13). Under Sections 12 and 31, the supply of export goods takes place on removal and issue of the invoice; turnover of zero-rated supply is therefore computed from invoices issued in the relevant period, subject to proof of actual export (para 13). The invoice and the shipping bill both fell within the relevant period and export was undisputed, so the Department's contention was "incongruous" (paras 14–15). The cause title was corrected under Rule 33(2) to name the Commissioner as appellant, and the appeal was rejected (paras 2, 16). Load more