Case Law
43,513 judgments · newest first · showing 25
Mandalaneni Srinivasarao-vs-Radical Bio Organics Limited-2026-juristway.com-3640-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST
Alt+← → switch · Alt+W close · right-click for options
2026-juristway.com-3640-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GSTMandalaneni Srinivasarao v Radical Bio Organics Limited
✓ Good LawDismissed2 Judge Bench
TreatmentNot yet cited by a later judgment
2026-juristway.com-3640-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST

Mandalaneni Srinivasarao

versus

Radical Bio Organics Limited

Court - Bench
GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) - Hyderabad
Date of Judgment
17 November 2026
Judges
Mr. A P Ravi, Member (Judicial), Mr. Duvvuri Krishna Srinivas, Member (Technical)
Case Number
APL/211/HYD/2026; Final Order No. 28/Court - II/HYD/2026
Advocate (Petitioner)
Shri P.V.V. Satyanarayana Murthy and Shri Mohd. Khalid
Advocate (Respondent)
Shri L. Venkateswara Rao - Advocate
Quick ref
Takeaway

July 2017 to March 2019 | Demand of Rs. 21,52,184 on payments to State departments | Department's appeal dismissed; penalty converted to Section 122(2)(a)

Distillery Licence Fee Not Supply — ENA Included

The entry in Notification No. 25/2019-CT (Rate) for grant of an alcoholic liquor licence is not limited to liquor for human consumption, so a distillery licence fee for ENA is not a supply. Renewal fees are covered by Entry 47, and metered raw water by Entry 99. Where suppression is not established, the demand and penalty fall to Section 73 and Section 122(2)(a).

Digest & Analysis
Litigation Digest

In Mandalaneni Srinivasarao v. Radical Bio Organics Ltd., 2026-juristway.com-3640-GSTAT(Hyderabad)-GST, where the Department appealed against the first appellate order deleting demands on licence fees and water charges paid by an ENA manufacturer and moving the royalty demand to Section 73, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench dismissed the appeal, deciding five issues against the Department.

Distillery licence fee: The entry has no words "for human consumption", ENA and rectified spirit are "liquor" under the Telangana Excise Act, 1968, and "by whatever name it is called" covers renewal fees (paras 13.5–13.13).

Boiler, factory, pollution and explosive licences: A renewal is a grant for a further period and is covered by Entry 47 of Notification No. 12/2017-CT (Rate) (paras 14.2–14.6).

Water charges: A charge computed per 1,000 gallons of metered raw water is the price of water, exempt under Entry 99 of Notification No. 2/2017-CT (Rate), whatever its name (paras 15.3–15.8).

Royalty and DMF contribution: Tax was admitted, but the payments were in the books, the levy was interpretational and GSTR-3B had no field for such inward supplies, so suppression was not established and Section 75(2) was rightly applied (paras 16.6–16.12).

Penalty: Section 122(2)(b) failed with Section 74; under Section 75(8) the penalty stands converted to Section 122(2)(a) and is to be recomputed (paras 16.0–17.0, second series).

Order: The appeal was disposed of on these terms (paras 18.0–20.0).

✎ Editor's Note

Practice point: Distilleries and manufacturers paying licence renewal, boiler, pollution and metered water charges to State departments can rely on this ruling against RCM demands for 2017–19. For royalty and DMF, where tax is admitted, keep the payments fully recorded in the books; that, with the interpretational history, defeats Section 74.

Risk: The Department may challenge the reading of Notification No. 25/2019 as extending to industrial alcohol, given the contrary line of Synthetics and Chemicals, which the Tribunal held inapplicable to licence fees.

Note on the text: Paragraph numbers 16.0 to 16.4 are used twice, and para 16.4 of the penalty discussion refers to "paragraph 15.10", meaning the findings at paras 16.10–16.11. The cause title names an officer as appellant; the appeal is the Department's.

Disclaimer: This content reflects the editor's personal views and should not be treated as a legal opinion or professional advice.

Full Text
Judgment & Order
14px