Case Law
43,435 judgments · newest first · showing 25
Manoj Traders-vs-Sanjay Kumar Pathak, Additional Commissioner Grade-II, U.P-2026-juristway.com-3561-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST
Alt+← → switch · Alt+W close · right-click for options
2026-juristway.com-3561-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GSTManoj Traders v Sanjay Kumar Pathak
✓ Good LawAllowed2 Judge Bench
TreatmentNot yet cited by a later judgment
2026-juristway.com-3561-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST

Manoj Traders

versus

Sanjay Kumar Pathak, Additional Commissioner Grade-II, U.P

Court - Bench
GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) - Lucknow
Date of Judgment
13 November 2026
Judges
Mr. Narendra Kumar, Member (Judicial), Mr. Alok Chopra, Member (Technical)
Case Number
APL/199/LCK/2026
Advocate (Petitioner)
Shri Sunil Kumar Jaiswal - Advocate
Advocate (Respondent)
Shri Sanjeev Kumar - Deputy Commissioner, SGST
Quick ref
Takeaway

April 2018 | Tax of Rs. 22,316.15 and equal penalty on loose slips of Rs. 4,46,323 set aside | Taxpayer's appeal allowed

Loose Order Slips Reconciled With Invoices — No Demand

Loose order slips found in a survey cannot be taxed as unaccounted sales where their entries are exempt goods or match invoices already recorded and reported in GSTR-3B. Taxing them again is double taxation.

Digest & Analysis
Litigation Digest

In Manoj Traders v. Commissioner of State Tax, U.P., 2026-juristway.com-3561-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST, where a kirana trader's first appeal left a 5% tax and penalty on Rs. 4,46,323 recorded in three loose slips seized in a 2018 survey, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Lucknow Bench found that the slips covered exempt loose atta and maida and goods billed on 23.04.2018 under invoices reported in April 2018 returns (paras 6.1.1–6.2.3). The Department could not verify the B2C data on the portal (para 6.2.1). The residual demand was set aside and any amount paid is to be refunded (Order).

✎ Editor's Note

Practice point: When loose slips are seized, map each entry to an invoice and return entry, and separate exempt items. A reconciliation table of that kind was decisive here.

Disclaimer: This content reflects the editor's personal views and should not be treated as a legal opinion or professional advice.

Full Text
Judgment & Order
14px