Case Law
43,610 judgments · newest first · showing 25
Sangha Erectors Private Limited-vs-Deputy Commissioner, State Tax Hamirpur Uttar Pradesh & Ors.-2026-juristway.com-3736-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST
Alt+← → switch · Alt+W close · right-click for options
2026-juristway.com-3736-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GSTSangha Erectors Private Limited v Deputy Commissioner
✓ Good LawAllowed2 Judge Bench
TreatmentNot yet cited by a later judgment
2026-juristway.com-3736-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST

Sangha Erectors Private Limited

versus

Deputy Commissioner, State Tax Hamirpur Uttar Pradesh & Ors.

Court - Bench
GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) - Prayagraj
Date of Judgment
19 November 2026
Judges
Mr. Mahtab Ahmad, Member (Judicial), Mr. Ashish Varma, Member (Technical)
Case Number
APL/53/ALB/2026
Advocate (Petitioner)
Aryan Mishra Saurabh Singh Gaurav Mishra
Advocate (Respondent)
Smt Vibha Mishra DCST, DCST/Sr Shri Suneel Kumar Nirmal ACST/Asr
Quick ref
Takeaway

FY 2018-19 and FY 2019-20 | Demands of Rs. 90,07,523.78 and Rs. 1,15,24,415.40 with interest and penalty | Taxpayer's appeals allowed

PAN-Level Form 26AS Mismatch Cannot Fix State Demand

A demand under Section 74 against one State registration cannot rest on the difference between PAN-level Form 26AS and the combined returns of several registrations. Each registration is a distinct person, and the Department must show material linking the unpaid tax to the registration noticed, even where the taxpayer's conduct supports an inference of suppression.

Digest & Analysis
Litigation Digest

In Sangha Erectors Private Limited v. Deputy Commissioner, State Tax, 2026-juristway.com-3736-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST, where demands for two years were raised on the Uttar Pradesh registration of a multi-State contractor by comparing Form 26AS with the aggregate returns of four and five State registrations, the Hon'ble GST Appellate Tribunal, Prayagraj Bench allowed the appeals, deciding four issues.

Jurisdictional foundation (for the taxpayer): The Uttar Pradesh returns tallied; no site, recipient, invoice or payer in the State was identified, yet the whole difference was taxed as intra-State supply. The notices lacked the jurisdictional fact (paras 15–16).

Burden and Form 26AS (for the taxpayer): Section 155 casts the burden only for input tax credit; Form 26AS may prompt inquiry but is not evidence of the supplies of a particular registration (paras 17–18).

Suppression (for the Revenue): Silence through an intimation, DRC-01A, notice and three reminders, with shifting explanations, was deliberate withholding amounting to suppression with intent to evade (paras 19–20).

Nexus (for the taxpayer): That intent was not shown to relate to Uttar Pradesh tax, so Section 74 failed (paras 21–22).

Order: Remand declined; orders set aside, notices quashed for this registration, and refund of pre-deposit to be considered within thirty days (paras 23–24, Order).

Detailed Case Analysis

(i) Whether the demands are sustainable when no nexus between the discrepancy and the Uttar Pradesh registration is shown. (ii) On whom the burden lies, the evidentiary value of Form 26AS, and whether Section 74 was validly invoked. (iii) Whether the orders are non-speaking and remand is warranted. (iv) Consequences for interest, penalty and refund (para 13).

Distinct persons and the jurisdictional fact (paras 15–16)

The Hon'ble Tribunal noted that the State Act extends only to Uttar Pradesh, that each registration is a distinct person under Section 25(4) and (5), and that State tax is levied only on intra-State supplies. A notice under Section 74(1) must go to the person chargeable with the unpaid tax, and the officer's opinion must rest on material relating to that person; this is a jurisdictional fact which an authority cannot assume wrongly, applying Raza Textiles and Calcutta Discount. The Department's own table showed identical GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B turnover for the State registration. The order recorded place of supply as “NA”. If an unreconciled all-India variance were chargeable by the State that first noticed it, every State could tax the same turnover.

Burden of proof and Form 26AS (paras 17–18)

There is no general provision requiring a taxpayer to disprove a demand on outward supply. An adverse inference from withheld records arises only after the Department has produced material connecting the discrepancy with the person proceeded against. Form 26AS may include advances, gross amounts, non-taxable receipts and receipts of other registrations; following Kush Constructions as persuasive, a demand cannot be raised on the difference without examining its reasons. No deductor was approached and no contract examined.

Suppression and intent (paras 19–22)

Applying Chemphar Drugs, Anand Nishikawa and Bajaj Auto, something positive beyond inaction is needed. Here repeated written queries went unanswered and explanations changed; the Hon'ble Tribunal inferred deliberate withholding and intent to evade, and distinguished Simplex. Section 74(1), however, concerns tax unpaid by the person noticed under the Act under which the notice issues. The inferred intent was to evade tax, not necessarily Uttar Pradesh tax, and non-reconciliation of all-India figures cannot supply the nexus.

Remand (para 23)

Remand under Section 113(1) was declined: the defect was not want of evidence curable by inquiry but absence of connecting material on data the Department held from the outset; remand would let it supplement an unsustainable case.

Both appeals were allowed. The Orders-in-Appeal dated 25.07.2025 and Orders-in-Original dated 21.05.2025 were set aside and the notices dated 24.10.2024 quashed so far as they propose a demand against GSTIN 09AAJCS9102M1ZV. Refund of amounts deposited under Section 107(6) or Section 112(8) is to be considered within thirty days of application. The judgment is not a finding on liability in other States (para 26, Order).

✎ Editor's Note

Practice point: Each registration is a distinct person, and Form 26AS may prompt inquiry but is not evidence of the supplies of a particular registration; no deductor or recipient was approached and no contract or invoice examined (paras 15–18). The appellant's failure to produce work orders, payment certificates, bank statements or a deductor-wise reconciliation led to a finding of suppression against it (paras 14, 20).

Risk: The finding of deliberate suppression with intent to evade stands (para 20). The judgment is not a finding on the liability of the appellant's registrations in other States (para 26).

Disclaimer: This content reflects the editor's personal views and should not be treated as a legal opinion or professional advice.

Full Text
Judgment & Order
14px