Allowing an intra-court appeal, the Calcutta High Court set aside a Section 73 order that demanded more than the show cause notice had proposed, while leaving the notice itself alive.

The Calcutta High Court has held that an adjudication order of a proper officer, being a final quasi-judicial determination, cannot be converted into a show cause notice (SCN), and that an order demanding more than the notice specified violates Section 75(7) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. [S.N. Chatterjee and Company v. State of West Bengal & Ors., 2026-juristway.com-3793-HC(Calcutta)-GST]

A Division Bench of Justice Rajarshi Bharadwaj and Justice Sudip Deb heard the appeal against a Single Judge’s order dated 25 Aug 2025. That order had directed that the adjudication order of 24 Apr 2024 be treated as an SCN, to which the appellant was to respond within three weeks.

The appellant carried out coal loading and transport work for Eastern Coalfields Limited during 2018-19. After scrutiny of its returns, an SCN in Form GST DRC‑01 was issued on 26 Dec 2023 under Section 73, alleging excess input tax credit and a wrong rate of tax. The order in Form GST DRC‑07 demanded ₹3,03,88,943 under each of the central and State heads. The Court recorded that the notice had quantified the proposed liability at ₹2,94,26,791.67 under each head.

The appellant argued that an order cannot be treated as a notice and that Section 75(7) bars a demand in excess of the notice. The State said it had no objection to the order being treated as an SCN.

The Court held that an SCN begins the adjudicatory process by informing the noticee of the allegations and the proposed demand, while an adjudication order is the culmination of that process. “The two instruments are, therefore, distinct in their nature, purpose and legal effect.” The Single Judge’s direction was set aside.

Section 75(7) provides that the tax, interest and penalty demanded in the order shall not exceed the amount specified in the notice, and that no demand shall be confirmed on grounds other than those in the notice. The proper officer had acted contrary to that bar.

The adjudication order was set aside solely on this ground. The Court expressed no opinion on the merits and clarified that the SCN is not invalidated, leaving the authorities free to proceed in accordance with law, subject to limitation. No costs were awarded.

2026-juristway.com-3793-HC(Calcutta)-GST