The Allahabad High Court upheld attachment of six Prayagraj properties held in the name of a man below the poverty line, finding the funds traced to another person who was the real owner.

Whether a transaction is benami must be judged from the whole chain of circumstances, and the fact that the price was not paid directly from the real owner’s bank account does not by itself defeat the finding, the Allahabad High Court has held. [Suraj Pal v. Initiating Officer, Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr., 2026-juristway.com-3606-HC(Allahabad)-PBPT]

Justice Anil Kumar-X dismissed an appeal against the Appellate Tribunal’s order of 3 Aug 2026, which had upheld the Adjudicating Authority’s order of 30 Dec 2024 confirming provisional attachment under the Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988 (PBPT Act).

Acting on a tax evasion petition, the Initiating Officer found that the appellant, said to be living below the poverty line, owned several immovable properties worth crores. His bank accounts showed deposits and withdrawals of over ₹20 crore, a large part traced to Mohammad Ashraf Siddiqui and his associates. Six properties in Prayagraj were provisionally attached under Section 24(3) on 25 Aug 2023.

The appellant claimed an independent property-dealing business and loan transactions. The Court found that these did not satisfactorily explain his dealings with Siddiqui. It relied on the substantial movement of funds, the transfer of land acquisition compensation, his financial profile, findings on who managed his bank accounts and the lack of particulars of the claimed loans.

Taken together, these supported the conclusion that he was not an independent purchaser. The intention of the parties and the beneficial nature of the transactions had to be assessed from the entire chain of circumstances, not merely from how the money was transferred.

The Court held that the material established, on a preponderance of probabilities, that the transactions fell within Section 2(9)(A), with the appellant as benamidar under Section 2(10) and Siddiqui as beneficial owner under Section 2(12). He had been given an effective opportunity to explain, and no perversity was shown. The appeal was dismissed.

2026-juristway.com-3606-HC(Allahabad)-PBPT