The Madhya Pradesh High Court refused to interfere with blocking of ₹23.78 lakh of an aluminium extruder’s credit, holding that an investigation report gives reasons to believe under Rule 86A.
An investigation report from the State’s anti-evasion wing finding that suppliers issued invoices without actual supply is sufficient material for the proper officer to form reasons to believe under Rule 86A of the CGST Rules, 2017, and Section 6 of the GST law bars parallel proceedings only on the same subject matter, the Madhya Pradesh High Court has held [MAA Narmada Aluminiumextrusion Private Limited v. The State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors., 2026-juristway.com-3531-HC(Madhya Pradesh)-GST].
The Division Bench of Chief Justice Alpesh Y. Kogje, who wrote the order, and Justice Vivek Jain dismissed a writ petition against an order of 10 Mar 2026 blocking ₹23,78,030 in the company’s electronic credit ledger (ECL).
The company argued that it had cooperated with summons, produced invoices, e-way bills, bank statements and transport records, and that suppliers admitted supplying aluminium scrap. It said the Central GST authorities had already searched its premises in 2025-26, verified stock and concluded proceedings after it paid the amount determined, so the State could not start parallel proceedings. It also said Rule 86A was invoked on vague allegations, without a hearing.
The State replied that the present action related to fraudulent ITC in 2025-26, based on a separate probe by the Joint Commissioner, State Tax, Anti-Evasion Bureau, Jabalpur, which found that Unique Trade and Company had issued invoices for aluminium scrap it had never bought, without paying tax under reverse charge. It added that Rule 86A does not require a prior notice or hearing.
The Court held that Section 6 was not attracted since the proceedings concerned a separate transaction and a fresh cause of action. The proper officer had formed his belief on the investigation report, as Rule 86A permits.
While the petition was pending, an order of 28 Sep 2026 under Section 74A held the ITC from three suppliers, Unique Trade and Company, Madhushree Metal and Mahakal Metal, bogus and raised a demand of ₹1,78,66,416, which the company sought to challenge by amendment. As the factual issues needed examination and an appeal was available, the Court declined to intervene and dismissed the petition, clarifying that its observations were not on the merits.
2026-juristway.com-3531-HC(Madhya Pradesh)-GST



