The Madras High Court dismissed a customs broker’s writ against a Section 114AA penalty in a gold dore import case, as he had admitted the origin certificates were never verified, leaving him to appeal.

A customs broker who admits that the genuineness of certificates of origin was not verified cannot seek writ relief against a penalty on the plea that he only filed the importer’s documents, the Madras High Court has held. [S. Shivshankar v. Commissioner of Customs, Chennai, 2026-juristway.com-3613-HC(Madras)-Customs]

Justice N. Senthilkumar dismissed a petition by the manager of a customs broker firm challenging an order-in-original of 18 Apr 2026 imposing a penalty on him under Section 114AA of the Customs Act, 1962.

The broker had filed bills of entry for an importer of gold dore bars from Guinea, a least developed country (LDC), claiming nil basic customs duty and cess under the Duty Free Tariff Preference scheme in Notification No. 96/2008-Cus. The Department alleged that the importer had used third-party suppliers in Dubai to obtain certificates of origin and other documents.

The broker argued that he had uploaded every document supplied by the importer, including the mining assay certificates, on the e-Sanchit facility, and had no reason to doubt them. He relied on a decision where a penalty on a broker alone under Section 114AA was set aside.

The Court held that the broker and the importer’s directors had both admitted before the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) that the certificates were not verified, and that the mandatory procedure under Rule 6 of the Customs (Administration of Rules of Origin under Trade Agreements) Rules, 2020 (CAROTAR) and Rule 20 of the Rules of Origin had not been followed. Although the broker later retracted his statement, he could not blow hot and cold by claiming protection as a mere agent.

The petition was dismissed with liberty to appeal. At the broker’s request after pronouncement, the Court directed that the time spent in the writ petition be taken into account in computing limitation.

2026-juristway.com-3613-HC(Madras)-Customs