The Madras High Court ordered release of blister copper detained in a free trade warehousing zone, holding Customs had not obtained prior permission under SEZ Rules and misdeclaration was not established.

Customs cannot investigate goods kept in a Special Economic Zone (SEZ) without the prior written permission required by Rule 28(5) of the SEZ Rules, 2006, which is mandatory and not a formality, the Madras High Court has held. [Aaapurti Renewable Energy India Private Limited v. Principal Commissioner of Customs Chennai III & Ors., 2026-juristway.com-3620-HC(Madras)-Customs]

Justice N. Senthilkumar heard two writ petitions by a warehousing company in a free trade warehousing zone (FTWZ) against detention of blister copper covered by two warehousing bills of entry of 1 Aug 2026. One consignment was in the SEZ and the other at the air cargo complex.

The company stores blister copper, or unrefined copper, under Customs Tariff Heading 7402 for foreign principals. It said earlier consignments with small residual gold had been tested by the Customs House laboratory, found below the 2% gold threshold in Note 5 to Chapter 71 and released. It relied on the SEZ’s standard operating procedure, which prescribes examination, sampling and testing of blister copper. The consignments were held after an e-mail from the Special Intelligence and Investigation Branch (SIIB).

The Court held that in the absence of a contrary test report or other evidence, misdeclaration was not established and the goods had been correctly declared as blister copper.

For the SEZ consignment, the Department produced no satisfaction note or proof of prior written permission from the competent authority. The note it relied on concerned only the air cargo consignment and could not be extended to the other. The action on the SEZ consignment was therefore unsustainable.

For the air cargo consignment, the Court found no bar to Customs drawing samples, but held that test results alone would not settle the case either way, and that the goods could be provisionally released on sufficient bond and sureties.

The petition on the SEZ consignment was allowed and the petition on the air cargo consignment was partly allowed.

2026-juristway.com-3620-HC(Madras)-Customs