The Bombay High Court quashed DGFT orders rejecting PVC resin import registrations over an ITC(HS) code mismatch never raised in deficiency letters, and ordered a fresh decision after a personal hearing.

The Directorate General of Foreign Trade (DGFT) cannot reject an application for an import Registration Certificate on a ground the applicant was never told about, the Bombay High Court has held, quashing three rejections based on a mismatch of ITC(HS) codes. [Prime Polychem Private Limited v. Union of India & Ors., 2026-juristway.com-3572-HC(Bombay)-Customs]

The Division Bench of Justice M.S. Karnik and Justice Sandesh D. Patil heard a challenge to orders dated 14 Sep 2026 rejecting the petitioner’s applications to register three irrevocable ICLCs. The orders said the ICLCs showed ITC(HS) code 39041090, while the applications were for 39041020, as applicable under Notification No. 25/2026-27 dated 24 Jul 2026.

The petitioner said it had answered every deficiency letter, and none raised the code mismatch. It explained that Thailand’s export system has no code 39041020, so the supplier used the closest code, 39041090, and that it had consistently described the goods as suspension grade PVC resin. It called the mismatch a curable documentary discrepancy.

The Department defended the orders as speaking orders but stated that Customs had no independent objection to clearing the consignments, which were held up only for want of the DGFT certificate.

The Court declined to wait for the DGFT’s reply. It held that the reason for rejection was never put to the petitioner, which had an explanation to offer, and so an opportunity ought to have been given.

The orders were quashed and the DGFT was directed to decide afresh after a personal hearing. The petitioner was to appear on 11 Nov 2026 at 11:00 a.m., and the DGFT was to decide within seven days of that appearance. The petitioner may then seek clearance from Customs.

2026-juristway.com-3572-HC(Bombay)-Customs