In three appeals, GST Appellate Tribunal benches at Lucknow and Thiruvananthapuram held that procedural lapses alone do not justify Section 129 penalties, but transport with neither e-invoice nor e-way bill does.

Three rulings of the GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) mark where a transit penalty under Section 129 of the CGST Act, 2017 stands or falls: a procedural lapse with full documentation does not attract it, but transport without both an e-invoice and an e-way bill does [Ajeet Kumar Singh v. Sona Enterprises, 2026-juristway.com-3551-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST; Neptune Sales Corporation v. AN Yadav, Addl. Comm. Gr-2 Appeal-II, State Tax Office Lucknow & Ors., 2026-juristway.com-3553-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST; Tasty Nut Industries v. The Commissioner of Keralam State GST Thiruvananthapuram, 2026-juristway.com-3562-GSTAT(Thiruvananthapuram)-GST].

Sona Enterprises. Santosh Kumar Srivastava, Member (Judicial), and Arvind Kumar, Member (Technical), dismissed the Revenue’s appeal over tax and penalty of ₹2,15,572 on hardware intercepted on 8 Feb 2020, where two invoices for the same consignment moved under a single e-way bill instead of one for each invoice under Rule 138. The Bench held that the discrepancy was procedural, with no material showing concealment of taxable value or an attempt to evade tax.

Neptune Sales. The same Bench dismissed a trader’s appeal against a penalty of ₹2,52,216 for goods moved from Kanpur Dehat to Lucknow without an e-invoice under Rule 48(4) or an e-way bill under Rule 138. It held that the registration of the parties and the absence of physical discrepancy did not extinguish the contravention, and that had the vehicle not been intercepted the omission would have gone unnoticed.

Tasty Nut Industries. Subramanya Rayaprol, Vice-President, who wrote the order, and Ramamoorthi Sriram, Member (Technical), set aside a penalty of ₹1,01,631 on 4,182 kg of cashew kernels moved on 14 Nov 2021 from the firm’s Tamil Nadu branch to its Kerala branch with a tax invoice and valid e-way bill, but no e-invoice. The Bench held that Section 129(1) cannot be invoked for non-issuance of an e-invoice when a proper tax invoice exists, and cannot be levied on the recipient where the transporter carries a proper invoice and valid e-way bill. Omissions under Rule 48 are for the jurisdictional officer to deal with in audit, scrutiny or assessment.

The penalties were thus deleted in Sona Enterprises and Tasty Nut Industries, and upheld in Neptune Sales.

2026-juristway.com-3551-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST | 2026-juristway.com-3553-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST | 2026-juristway.com-3562-GSTAT(Thiruvananthapuram)-GST