The Allahabad High Court appointed a sole arbitrator in thirteen disputes by minority shareholders of a carpet company over the price paid for their shares, rejecting objections based on Form SH-4 and NCLT jurisdiction.
A seller’s claim for the balance price and tax indemnity under a negotiated share purchase agreement (SPA) is arbitrable, and objections that the dispute belongs before the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) or was superseded by the share transfer form are for the arbitral tribunal, the Allahabad High Court has held. [Awadh Narayan Tiwari & Ors. v. Surya Mani Tiwari & Anr., 2026-juristway.com-3599-HC(Allahabad)-INDLAW]
Justice Piyush Agrawal decided thirteen applications under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 by a common order. In the lead case, the applicant held 1.94% of Surya Carpet Private Limited. After disputes over the transfer of the company’s US subsidiary to an entity controlled by the managing director’s son, the minority agreed to exit. Under an SPA of 4 Nov 2019, the applicant sold 5,400 shares for ₹2,36,84,211, and the buyer undertook to indemnify him against capital gains tax.
He alleged that the valuation report behind the price was never disclosed and that the price implied a company value of about ₹122 crore, against a book value above ₹284 crore. He invoked clause 9.1 of the SPA in 2023.
The respondents argued that the governing contract was the statutory transfer form, Form SH‑4, which has no arbitration clause. They also argued that the dispute alleged oppression and lay exclusively with the NCLT under Section 430 of the Companies Act, 2013.
The Court held that the enquiry at this stage is confined to the prima facie existence of an arbitration agreement, citing SBI General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Krish Spinning (2024). The SPA was not a bare agreement to agree: it had independent covenants on price, indemnity and dispute resolution. Form SH‑4 only perfects title, and whether it discharged the SPA is for the tribunal.
The applicant claimed no relief as a member, having exited in 2019, and the NCLT has no general power to award such money claims. Objections on the articles of association, fraud and limitation did not show the claims to be ex facie non-arbitrable.
The Court appointed Justice Manoj Kumar Gupta, former Chief Justice of the Uttarakhand High Court, as sole arbitrator in all thirteen cases, with separate fees for each, and listed the matter for 30 Nov 2026.
2026-juristway.com-3599-HC(Allahabad)-INDLAW



