The GSTAT Ernakulam Bench upheld recovery of ₹67,993 excess refund from an exporter, holding that Rule 89(4) must be applied on net credit in its own returns.

Refund of unutilised input tax credit (ITC) on exports under a letter of undertaking (LUT) must be computed under Rule 89(4) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017 (CGST Rules) on the net ITC shown in the exporter’s own GSTR‑3B returns, the Ernakulam Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) has held. [Popular Industries v. Commissioner of CGST, Kochi, 2026-juristway.com-3595-GSTAT(Ernakulam)-GST]

The Bench of Subramanya Rayaprol, Vice-President, who wrote the order, and Ramamoorthi Sriram, Member (Technical), dismissed the exporter’s appeal against an order-in-appeal dated 14 Sep 2021.

The exporter had claimed ₹6,24,536 under Section 54(3) for February and March 2018. The Assistant Commissioner sanctioned ₹6,16,479 by order dated 24 Jan 2019. On review, the Commissioner found the eligible amount to be ₹5,48,486, and the appellate authority upheld the Department’s appeal, reducing net ITC by ₹1,58,760.

The exporter argued that net ITC had been wrongly reduced and that it had reversed some credit of an earlier period. The Tribunal verified the figures from its GSTR‑3B returns and found net ITC of ₹12,11,181 for the period. Applying the formula, the eligible refund was ₹5,48,486, so ₹67,993 had been sanctioned in excess.

The Tribunal held that the claimed reversals were unsupported by any Form DRC‑03 or DRC‑03A or other proof, before either authority, and that bare statements of reversal cannot be accepted. It found that the net ITC in the refund claim differed from Table 4(C) of GSTR‑3B, and that the appellant had not come with clean hands. It accepted the Department’s point that reducing an earlier refund claim and later debiting the ledger were separate events, so there was no double reversal.

The appeal was rejected and the order-in-appeal was upheld.

2026-juristway.com-3595-GSTAT(Ernakulam)-GST