The Appellate Tribunal under SAFEMA reduced a ₹3.72 crore FEMA penalty on West Bridge Ventures to ₹92,94,250, though it upheld the finding that rights shares were acquired without RBI permission.

A penalty equal to the full amount invested in rights shares acquired without Reserve Bank of India (RBI) approval is grossly irrational and disproportionate where all transactions went through banking channels and nothing was suppressed, the Appellate Tribunal under SAFEMA has held [West Bridge Ventures II LLC v. The Directorate of Enforcement, Chennai, 2026-juristway.com-3513-AT (SAFEMA)(New Delhi)-FEMA].

Justice Munishwar Nath Bhandari, Chairman, partly allowed an appeal under Section 19 of the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (FEMA) against an order of 6 Jan 2023 of the Special Director, Directorate of Enforcement, imposing a penalty of ₹3,71,77,000.

The foreign investor acquired 33,600 equity shares of Vasan Health Care Private Limited from its director, Dr. A.M. Arun, under an agreement of 21 Oct 2010 at ₹7,500 a share, for ₹25,20,00,000. Five days later it signed a profit-sharing agreement under which part of any return above 30% on a later sale would go to the sellers. In May 2014 it subscribed to Series E and F compulsorily convertible preference shares (CCPS) in a rights issue for ₹3,71,77,000.

The Special Director held that the CCPS acquisition breached Section 6(3)(b) of FEMA read with Regulations 3 and 6(2)(iii) of the Foreign Exchange Management (Transfer or Issue of Security by a Person Resident Outside India) Regulations, 2000.

The Tribunal rejected the plea that the opinion should have been served on it, noting that under Rule 4(3) of the adjudication rules and the Bombay High Court ruling in Shashank Vyankatesh Manohar, this is required only where the noticee objects and seeks a copy, which had not happened.

On merits, it agreed that the second proviso to Regulation 3 required an application to RBI, which was not made. But the Department had taken no action on the 2010 acquisition and penalised only the 2014 rights shares, all paid through banking channels.

Calling a penalty of the full amount grossly irrational and disproportionate, the Tribunal reduced it to 25% of the amount involved, ₹92,94,250.

2026-juristway.com-3513-AT (SAFEMA)(New Delhi)-FEMA