The Madras High Court quashed a demand for 2% monthly interest on delayed VAT payment for 2008-09, holding that the 2013 increase from 1.25% was prospective.
The increase in the rate of interest on delayed tax payments under Section 42(3) of the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act (TNVAT Act) from 1.25% to 2% a month, made from 29 May 2013, is prospective and cannot apply to an earlier assessment, the Madras High Court has held. [K.C. Jothinathan v. State Tax Officer (FAC), Dharmapuri, 2026-juristway.com-3598-HC(Madras)-VAT/CST]
Justice S. Raveekumar allowed a writ petition against proceedings dated 12 Nov 2022 directing the dealer to pay interest at 2% for the period from 21 Nov 2012 to 18 Oct 2021.
The revised assessment for 2008-09 was passed on 21 Nov 2012, and the tax was paid on 17 Oct 2021. The dealer argued that, under Section 42(3) as it then stood, interest for belated payment could be charged only at 1.25% a month. He also challenged the penalty.
The Court held that the amending Act did not give retrospective effect to the higher rate, and that the amendment was neither clarificatory nor declaratory. It could not be applied to an earlier assessment year or to a case where the assessment order was passed before the amendment, so interest could be levied only at 1.25% a month.
The demand at 2% was set aside, and the matter was remanded for interest to be collected at 1.25% for the period of delay, within four weeks of receipt of the order.
The Court declined to examine the penalty, since the assessment order of 21 Nov 2012 that imposed it was not under challenge.
2026-juristway.com-3598-HC(Madras)-VAT/CST



