The Patna High Court quashed criminal proceedings against a statutory auditor after the Regional Director compounded the underlying audit-reporting contravention for ₹30,000.
Once the contravention forming the basis of a prosecution has been compounded by the competent authority and the fee paid, the prosecution cannot continue, the Patna High Court has held, quashing proceedings against a company’s statutory auditor. [Subodh Kumar Goel v. State of Bihar & Ors., 2026-juristway.com-3563-HC(Patna)-CORP]
Justice Ansul heard a petition against an order dated 2 Aug 2016 of the Special Judge, Economic Offences, Patna, taking cognizance under Section 233 of the Companies Act, 1956 for an alleged breach of Section 227(3)(d), which required the auditor to report on compliance with accounting standards. The Registrar of Companies alleged that the auditor had not qualified his report on depreciation, disposal of fixed assets and managerial remuneration.
The proceedings were stayed in 2018. Meanwhile, the auditor applied to the Regional Director under Section 441 of the Companies Act, 2013. On 19 Oct 2022, with the Registrar’s report noting the pending prosecution and raising no objection, the Regional Director compounded the contravention for a fee of ₹30,000, which was paid.
The Court relied on V.L.S. Finance Ltd. v. Union of India (2013), where the Supreme Court held that compounding may be done even after prosecution begins and the accused is then to be discharged. It noted that Section 441(3)(d) of the 2013 Act requires the Registrar to inform the trial court of compounding, upon which the officer is discharged.
The Registrar had not informed the Special Judge, but the Court held that this procedural lapse could not keep alive a prosecution whose foundation had ceased to exist, particularly as the compounding authority knew of the pending case.
The cognizance order and the proceedings against the auditor were quashed. The Court did not examine the merits of the accounting allegations.
2026-juristway.com-3563-HC(Patna)-CORP


