The GSTAT Ernakulam Bench set aside a vehicle-check penalty on a Tamil Nadu supplier of pumps, holding the Kerala officer lacked jurisdiction without a temporary ID and that e-invoice lapses belong to assessment.

A penalty under Section 129(1) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST Act) cannot be imposed merely because goods moved without an e-invoice, where a proper tax invoice and valid e-way bill accompanied them, the Ernakulam Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) has held. [Super Teck Industries v. Commissioner of State GST, Thiruvananthapuram, 2026-juristway.com-3594-GSTAT(Ernakulam)-GST]

The Bench of Subramanya Rayaprol, Vice-President, who wrote the order, and Ramamoorthi Sriram, Member (Technical), allowed the appeal of a Coimbatore firm whose consignment of 200 open well pumps to Kochi was intercepted at Walayar on 11 Feb 2021.

Physical verification found no discrepancy between the goods and the invoice and e-way bill. The only lapse was the absence of an e-invoice, which the firm generated the next day. The Department argued that e-invoicing was mandatory under Rule 48(4) for its turnover and that, without the interception, the lapse would have gone unnoticed.

On jurisdiction, the Tribunal held that the Assistant State Tax Officer, Palakkad, issued the notice in Form GST MOV‑07 and the order in Form GST MOV‑09 to a person registered in Tamil Nadu without generating a temporary ID, which was created only on 28 Jun 2021 for the summary order in Form GST DRC‑07. Notices and orders issued before that were held to be without jurisdiction.

On merits, it held that any omission under Rule 48(4) is for the supplier’s jurisdictional officer to address in scrutiny, assessment or audit, and that Section 129(1) cannot be invoked for it when a proper tax invoice exists. It relied on Osel Devices Limited v. Assistant Enforcement Officer (2024) of the Kerala High Court and Nancy Trading Company v. State of U.P. (2024) of the Allahabad High Court.

Forms GST MOV‑07 and MOV‑09 were declared void ab initio, and the order-in-appeal dated 30 Dec 2021 was set aside with consequential relief.

2026-juristway.com-3594-GSTAT(Ernakulam)-GST