In two Department appeals, the Agra Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal upheld the cancellation of penalties for a blank Part-B and for a repair consignment whose e-way bill came after interception.

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Agra Bench, has held that a penalty under Section 129(3) of the Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 cannot rest on a technical e-way bill lapse where the documents show a genuine movement of goods and no intent to evade tax. [Ram Kumar Yadav v. Jalaj Alia, Agra, 2026-juristway.com-3788-GSTAT(Agra)-GST; Commissioner State Tax U.P v. Acevector Limited, Gurugram, Haryana, 2026-juristway.com-3789-GSTAT(Agra)-GST]

The Bench comprised Ajeet Singh, Member (Judicial), and Vivek Kumar, Member (Technical). Section 129 provides for detention of goods in transit and a penalty where they are moved in contravention of the Act or the rules.

Jalaj Alia. In an order by Ajeet Singh, the Bench dealt with a machine that developed a defect and was sent from Vidisha in Madhya Pradesh to Faridabad in Haryana for repair. It travelled with the original purchase invoice, a transport bilty and a delivery challan under Rule 55. The vehicle was intercepted at Lalitpur on 8 Jul 2023 without an e-way bill, which the taxpayer generated the same day, before any notice issued. The Bench accepted that Rule 138 requires an e-way bill even for movements that are not a supply, but called the lapse a “venial and technical breach”. Referring to Assistant Commissioner, State Tax and others vs Satyam Shivam Papers, pvt. Ltd. (2022), it held that the penalty could not be imposed mechanically.

Acevector. In an order by Vivek Kumar, the Bench dealt with goods moving from Gurugram to Hosur in Tamil Nadu that were intercepted at Lalitpur on 18 Sep 2024. E-invoices and e-way bills were produced, but Part-B, which carries the vehicle details, had not been updated. A penalty of ₹5,12,676 was imposed, and the first appellate authority set it aside on 7 Jan 2025.

The taxpayer objected that the amount in dispute was below the monetary limit in the State Tax Commissioner’s circular dated 5 Jul 2024. The Bench rejected this, as the circular excludes cases the Commissioner considers it necessary to contest in the interest of justice or revenue. On merits, the e-invoices had been generated on the portal before the movement, and the penalty order recorded no finding of intent to evade. The Bench followed M/s Citykart Retail Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner Commercial Tax (Writ C No. 22285 of 2019) of the Allahabad High Court.

The Bench added that Uttar Pradesh was only a transit State. Citing the Allahabad High Court’s ruling in M/s Maruti enterprises vs State of U.P (2026), it said such a State may inspect and verify goods but cannot exercise penal jurisdiction under Section 129 over a consignment that neither starts nor ends there.

Both Department appeals were dismissed and the first appellate orders upheld.

2026-juristway.com-3788-GSTAT(Agra)-GST | 2026-juristway.com-3789-GSTAT(Agra)-GST