GST Appellate Tribunal benches at Chandigarh and Lucknow reached opposite outcomes on Section 130, quashing confiscation of goods in transit without nexus but restoring it for unrecorded stock found in a search.
Two benches of the GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) have applied Section 130 of the CGST Act, 2017 to different facts: goods in transit cannot be confiscated on a general allegation about the trader’s past credit, but unrecorded stock physically found in a search can be [R.K. Enterprises v. K.S. Chahal, Deputy Excise and Taxation Commissioner, Patiala, 2026-juristway.com-3550-GSTAT(Chandigarh)-GST; Santosh Kumar Singh v. Agarwal Flexi Pack, 2026-juristway.com-3552-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST].
R.K. Enterprises. Jatinder Pal Singh, Member (Judicial), and Pradeep Kumar Goel, Member (Technical), allowed a trader’s appeal. Aluminium scrap in transit was checked on 10 Nov 2022 with a tax invoice, transporter’s note, e-way bill and weighment slip, but detained for verification. An SCN of 22 Nov 2022 alleged that the trader had claimed credit from suppliers not paying tax, and the goods and vehicle were confiscated. The Bench held that without any allegation or evidence linking the allegedly ineligible inward supplies to the goods detained, confiscation could not be justified, so no penalty under Section 122 could follow. It also directed that, under Rule 33(1) of the GST Appellate Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 2025, the Commissioner and not the appellate officer is the respondent.
Agarwal Flexi Pack. Santosh Kumar Srivastava, Member (Judicial), and Arvind Kumar, Member (Technical), allowed the Revenue’s appeal. A search on 5 Dec 2019 of a Kanpur packaging manufacturer, which had paid no cash tax for two months, found raw materials and finished goods worth ₹8.36 lakh in excess of the books, recorded in a signed stock inventory. The Bench held that Section 130(1)(ii) independently applies where goods on which tax is payable are not accounted for, and that the first appellate authority wrongly disregarded the signed panchnama. It also overruled the objection that the ₹3,01,000 demand was below the ₹20 lakh limit for departmental appeals, holding that the dispute fell within the exclusions in Circular No. 207/01/2024-GST.
The confiscation in Chandigarh was quashed with consequential relief, while the confiscation order in Lucknow was restored in full.
2026-juristway.com-3550-GSTAT(Chandigarh)-GST | 2026-juristway.com-3552-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST



