The GST Appellate Tribunal at Ghaziabad dismissed the Revenue’s appeal over a ₹99.62 lakh transitional credit demand, holding that it rested on a ground the show cause notice never raised.
A demand disallowing transitional credit cannot be sustained on the ground that it consists of tax deducted at source (TDS) under the State VAT law when the show cause notice (SCN) never framed that charge, and the Tribunal will not remand merely so that the Department can build a fresh case, the GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Ghaziabad has held [Suniti Ranjan Sharma v. Systematic Conscom Ltd., 2026-juristway.com-3534-GSTAT(Ghaziabad)-GST].
The Bench of Dr. Sanjay Kumar Chandhariyavi, Member (Judicial), and Sungita Sharma, Member (Technical), dismissed the State’s appeal against an order of 15 Oct 2022 of the first appellate authority.
The respondent, a trader and works contractor in Uttar Pradesh, carried a balance of ₹99,63,376 into GST through Form GST TRAN‑1, of which ₹97,73,630 represented refundable TDS deducted from its works-contract receipts under the Uttar Pradesh Value Added Tax Act, 2008. Notice No. 320 of 7 Aug 2018 under Section 73 compared the claim with just ₹607 of credit shown in the June 2017 VAT return and complained that Form C particulars had not been furnished. A demand of tax of ₹99,62,769, interest of ₹26,39,998 and penalty of ₹9,96,277 was raised on 21 Jan 2019 and set aside in first appeal.
Relying on Commissioner of Central Excise v. Brindavan Beverages (2007) and Oryx Fisheries Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India (2010), the Tribunal held that the SCN is the foundation of the Revenue’s case. It had not identified any amount as TDS or alleged that such an amount was legally incapable of transition. The Form C objection had been dropped, and the final demand was not reconciled component-wise with the grounds in the notice.
The Tribunal declined to rule in the abstract on whether VAT TDS can ever be carried into TRAN‑1 under Section 140(1). Citing Mangalore Chemicals & Fertilisers Ltd. (1992), it noted that the VAT assessments for the relevant years were pending, and departmental delay cannot be treated as proof against the taxpayer.
Holding that a remand to frame a new charge would not cure the defects, the Tribunal dismissed the appeal and confirmed the deletion of the demand.
2026-juristway.com-3534-GSTAT(Ghaziabad)-GST


