The Rajasthan and Delhi High Courts sent taxpayers challenging Section 74 orders to the appellate authority, holding that disputes over secondment contracts and service of hearing notices need evidence, not writ jurisdiction.

A writ petition against an order under Section 74 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST Act) should not be entertained where the dispute turns on facts that need evidence, the Rajasthan and Delhi High Courts have held in two separate rulings, relegating the taxpayers to appeal under Section 107. [Astemo India Private Limited v. Additional Commissioner (AE) & Ors., 2026-juristway.com-3605-HC(Rajasthan)-GST; Saachi Exports India v. Union of India & Anr., 2026-juristway.com-3609-HC(Delhi)-GST]

Astemo India. The Division Bench of Justice Arun Monga and Justice Ashutosh Kumar, in a judgment by Justice Monga, dismissed a challenge to an order of 13 Jan 2025 confirming integrated tax of ₹11,19,39,126 under reverse charge, denying input tax credit (ITC) of ₹5,23,25,805 and imposing an equal penalty for July 2017 to March 2023. The Department treated the secondment of Japanese employees by the parent company as an import of manpower supply service, following Commissioner of Customs v. Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. (2022). The company said they were its own employees.

The Court held that who the employer is, who bears the salary, who controls the employees, lien on service and the company’s own conduct were all disputed facts that could not be resolved on affidavits. The appeal hierarchy up to the High Court under Section 117 is complete. A complaint that the officer did not deal well with the replies is a ground of appeal, not a denial of hearing. The company may appeal within 30 days without limitation objection, with no coercive steps for that period, and whether its deposit of ₹6,00,66,553 counts as pre-deposit is left to the appellate authority.

Saachi Exports India. The Division Bench of Justice Anil Kshetarpal and Justice Bharat Parashar, in a judgment by Justice Kshetarpal, disposed of four petitions against an order of 4 Feb 2025 confirming demands for wrongful ITC from alleged bogus firms. The firms said their requests for hearing were ignored and notices were not served. The Court held that whether hearing notices were dispatched and served under Section 169 needs departmental records and postal proof, citing Assistant Commissioner of State Tax v. Commercial Steel Limited (2022). Fourteen appeals against the same order were already pending.

In both cases the Courts expressed no view on merits and allowed the time spent in the writ courts to be considered when computing limitation for the appeals.

2026-juristway.com-3605-HC(Rajasthan)-GST | 2026-juristway.com-3609-HC(Delhi)-GST