Deciding a dealer’s appeal and the Department’s cross-objection together, the Dehradun Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal upheld a recomputed demand of ₹8,92,274 and deleted a ₹50,000 general penalty.
The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Dehradun Bench, has held that a dealer who wrongly stayed in the composition scheme after crossing the turnover limit is to be taxed at the normal rate by treating its receipts as inclusive of tax under Section 15 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 read with Rule 35 of the Rules, but cannot now claim input tax credit (ITC) on its purchases or opening stock. [Narula Bicycle’s Junction v. Commissioner CGST Dehradun, 2026-juristway.com-3769-GSTAT(Dehradun)-GST; Asagar Hussain v. Narula Bicycle’s Junction, Dehradun, 2026-juristway.com-3771-GSTAT(Dehradun)-GST]
Naresh Katyal, Member (Judicial), authored the common order for the Bench, which included Amand Shah, Member (Technical). The composition scheme in Section 10 lets small dealers pay tax at a flat rate on turnover without charging tax to customers or taking credit.
The dealer sells bicycles and toys taxable at 12%. Its turnover of ₹1,42,97,621 in 2018-19 exceeded the limit, making it a regular taxpayer from 1 Apr 2019, yet it paid 1% on its 2019-20 turnover of ₹91,85,178. A show cause notice under Section 73 was issued on 22 May 2024, and an order dated 20 Aug 2024 demanded ₹10,10,370. On 3 Jul 2025 the Commissioner (Appeals) recomputed the tax on a cum-tax basis at ₹9,84,126, deducted ₹91,852 already paid, and fixed the balance at ₹8,92,274. He refused the ITC claim.
The dealer said a part-time accountant had advised that the limit was ₹150 lakh. It sought credit on inward supplies of 2019-20 and on stock held on 31 Mar 2019 under Sections 16 and 18(1)(c). The Department challenged the cum-tax computation.
The Bench upheld the recomputation. Section 10(4) bars a composition dealer from collecting tax, so the consideration received must be treated as inclusive of tax. It followed Shri Parameshwara Bricks Vs. State Tax office (APL/26/HYD/2026) of the Hyderabad Bench.
The ITC claim failed. The credit was never claimed in any return, and Section 16(5) protects only credit claimed in returns filed up to 30 Nov 2021. Section 18(2) bars credit on stock after one year from the date of the invoice, so the window for stock held on 31 Mar 2019 closed by 31 Mar 2020. The Bench said that retrospective conversion to a regular taxpayer “does not automatically revive or extend the already lapsed timeline” for the credit.
Interest and the penalty of ₹44,614 under each Act under Section 73 were upheld. The general penalty of ₹25,000 under each Act under Section 125 was set aside in view of Section 75(13). The dealer’s appeal was dismissed with that modification.
2026-juristway.com-3769-GSTAT(Dehradun)-GST | 2026-juristway.com-3771-GSTAT(Dehradun)-GST



