Allowing the State’s appeal, the Dehradun Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal restored the denial of ₹31,32,370 credit to a packaging firm that filed its 2018-19 returns in February 2023.

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Dehradun Bench, has held that the time limit for taking input tax credit (ITC) in Section 16(4) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 is mandatory, and that the relief in Section 16(5) is available only where the GSTR‑3B return was furnished by 30 Nov 2021. [Deputy Commissioner on Behalf of Commissioner of State Tax Department v. Mansa Packaging, 2026-juristway.com-3770-GSTAT(Dehradun)-GST]

Naresh Katyal, Member (Judicial), authored the order for the Bench, which included Amand Shah, Member (Technical).

The respondent manufactures packaging material at Haridwar. It did not file returns for July 2018 to March 2019 in time. On 23 Feb 2023 it filed GSTR‑1 and GSTR‑3B with tax, interest and late fee, a delay of about 1,200 days, and claimed ITC of ₹31,32,370. A show cause notice under Section 73 followed on 26 Dec 2023. By an order dated 20 Mar 2024 the credit was disallowed, with a penalty of ₹1,56,618 under each of the central and State Acts and interest. On 7 Jul 2025 the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) set that order aside as resting on procedural grounds, holding the credit reflected in GSTR‑2A to be genuine.

The respondent argued that Section 16(4) is procedural, that the tax was paid and the transactions were genuine, and that the late fee and interest had already penalised it. It also complained that it was not heard. The Bench called the adjudicating authority’s failure to give a proper hearing improper, but proceeded to decide the merits as both sides had been fully heard in the first appeal and before it.

The Bench held that ITC is a statutory concession and that the time limit cannot be stretched. It relied on Thirumala Plywoods v. Assistant Commissioner (Writ Petition No. 24235 of 2022) of the Andhra Pradesh High Court, which held that paying a late fee does not cure the time bar, and on Chief Commissioner of Central Goods and Services Tax & Ors. v. M/s. Safari Retreats Pvt. Ltd. (2024 INSC 756).

Section 16(5), inserted in 2024, overrides Section 16(4) for 1 Jul 2017 to 31 Mar 2021 only if the return for those periods was furnished by 30 Nov 2021. A return filed on 23 Feb 2023 does not qualify.

The appellate order was set aside and the original order restored, including the penalty and interest at 18%. The Bench noted that under Section 50(3) and Rule 88B, interest arises only where wrongly availed credit is also utilised.

2026-juristway.com-3770-GSTAT(Dehradun)-GST