The Prayagraj Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal cut a Section 74 tax demand from ₹13,97,074 to ₹3,47,826, but upheld additions based on seized sale records owned on oath.

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Prayagraj Bench, has held that the difference between the value at which a dealer carries closing stock in the books and the value of the same stock at average purchase cost is not a supply, and cannot be taxed under Section 74 of the Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. [Raj Trading Company v. Commissioner Concerned Uttar Pradesh Lucknow, 2026-juristway.com-3785-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST]

Ashish Varma, Member (Technical), wrote the judgment for the Bench, which included Mahtab Ahmad, Member (Judicial).

The appellant deals in iron and steel at Naini, Prayagraj. On 29 Nov 2022 the Special Investigation Branch surveyed the premises and seized three booklets of sale slips carrying no firm name, a manual invoice book and loose slips. The first appellate authority confirmed tax of ₹13,97,074 on six heads. The largest, ₹58,29,156, arose from revaluing the closing stock of 182.733 MT, carried in the books at ₹35,81,594, at ₹51.50 per kg.

The Bench deleted that addition. Tax is charged by Section 9 on a supply, it said, and “A difference between two valuations of the same stock is a difference in valuation, and it is not a sale.” Goods found lying at the premises cannot at the same time be treated as sold. Section 35(6) deems a supply only for goods that are not accounted for. On that basis, a shortage of 5.3 MT against the book stock was held taxable.

On the seized papers, the appellant relied on CBI v. V.C. Shukla (1998) to argue that loose sheets cannot fasten liability. The Bench accepted the principle but distinguished it. The papers were found at her own registered premises, her authorised representative claimed them as the firm’s records in a sworn statement under Section 70 that was never retracted, and a large part of the entries matched her own books. The onus therefore shifted to her to explain the rest.

Section 74 was held to apply. Suppression is tested when a return is furnished, and the appellant filed her later returns without declaring the supplies recorded in the seized papers. Her plea that payments made through Form GST DRC‑03 were extracted under pressure was rejected.

Tax of ₹3,47,826 was confirmed with an equal penalty. After adjusting the DRC‑03 payments of ₹6,90,000, a penalty balance of ₹5,652 remains. Surplus cash pre-deposit is to be refunded within sixty days of receipt of the order.

2026-juristway.com-3785-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST