The Prayagraj Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal set aside Section 74 demands for two years, though it inferred suppression from the company’s silence, as no link to Uttar Pradesh was shown.

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Prayagraj Bench, has held that an unreconciled difference between a permanent account number (PAN) level Form 26AS and the combined returns of a company’s registrations in several States cannot be taxed in the hands of one State registration under Section 74 of the Uttar Pradesh Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 unless the Department shows a nexus with that registration. [Sangha Erectors Private Limited v. Deputy Commissioner, State Tax Hamirpur & Ors., 2026-juristway.com-3736-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST]

Ashish Varma, Member (Technical), wrote the judgment for the Bench, which included Mahtab Ahmad, Member (Judicial). Form 26AS is the income-tax statement of tax deducted at source against a PAN, and Section 74 covers tax unpaid by reason of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts.

The appellant erects power plants and held 13 registrations under one PAN. Show cause notices (SCNs) dated 24 Oct 2024, issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Hamirpur, compared the Form 26AS turnover with the returns and treated a shortfall of ₹157.12 lakh for 2018-19 and ₹281.15 lakh for 2019-20 as intra-State supply. Orders dated 21 May 2025 confirmed tax, interest and equal penalty totalling ₹90,07,523.78 and ₹1,15,24,415.40, and the first appeals were dismissed on 25 Jul 2025. The returns figures combined four and five State registrations, while the Uttar Pradesh registration’s GSTR‑1 and GSTR‑3B for 2018-19 showed identical turnover.

The appellant argued that the officer acted beyond his territory and that the ingredients of Section 74 were absent. The Department replied that the appellant failed to reconcile the figures despite repeated opportunities and produced no primary evidence.

The Bench held that each registration is a distinct person under Section 25(4), and that material showing tax unpaid by the person noticed is a jurisdictional fact. “Were an unreconciled all-India variance chargeable to the State that first notices it, every State could tax the same turnover.” Form 26AS may prompt an inquiry but is not evidence of the taxable supplies of a particular registration, it said, drawing on Kush Constructions v. CGST, NACIN, Kanpur (Final Order No. 70323/2019).

The Bench was critical of the appellant, which did not answer the 2023 intimations and gave shifting explanations. It inferred a deliberate withholding of information after query, amounting to suppression with intent to evade tax. That inference, however, did not supply the missing link with the Uttar Pradesh registration.

Declining a remand under Section 113(1), the Bench allowed both appeals, set aside the orders and quashed the SCNs so far as they concern the Uttar Pradesh registration. A refund application for the pre-deposit is to be considered within thirty days of its receipt. The Bench clarified that it made no finding on liability in other States.

2026-juristway.com-3736-GSTAT(Prayagraj)-GST