The Rajasthan High Court quashed a ₹73.43 crore GST notice against the Jaipur Development Authority, holding that a State body whose officers gain nothing cannot be presumed to intend tax evasion.
A notice under Section 74 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST Act) is without jurisdiction if it does not disclose an intent to evade tax, and that intent cannot be attributed to a State authority run by public servants who stand to gain nothing, the Rajasthan High Court has held. [Jaipur Development Authority v. Additional Commissioner, CGST Audit & Ors., 2026-juristway.com-3582-HC(Rajasthan)-GST]
The Division Bench of Justice Arun Monga and Justice Ashutosh Kumar, in a judgment written by Justice Monga, quashed a show cause notice (SCN) dated 30 Sep 2025 covering 2019-20 to 2023-24. It proposed tax of ₹73.43 crore on road cutting charges, additional floor area ratio (FAR) charges and betterment levy, and the sale of Master Plan booklets and forms.
The receipts were found in the Authority’s own books during an audit under Section 65. The same audit report had produced six other notices from a Superintendent a day earlier. The Department argued that a writ does not lie against an SCN and that non-disclosure and non-payment showed wilful suppression.
The Court accepted that a writ court ordinarily does not interfere at the notice stage, but held that the rule is one of self-restraint, not a bar. Fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression “to evade tax” are jurisdictional facts for Section 74, which carries a five-year limitation and a penalty equal to the tax.
It rejected the plea that alleging both misstatement and suppression vitiates a notice, since the two often overlap. But Explanation 2 to Section 74, which defines suppression, does not dispense with the separate requirement of intent to evade. Intent is a state of mind; the Authority is headed by an IAS officer on deputation, and nothing showed any gain to those in charge.
The Bench added that attributing evasion to State officers could lead to one government officer prosecuting another under Section 132. It clarified that a public authority is not immune where the record shows deliberate falsification or a collateral purpose.
The notice and all proceedings under it were quashed. The Court also observed, without making it a direction, that the parties should explore settlement through the Government of India in the spirit of the Department of Public Enterprises’ dispute-resolution mechanism.
2026-juristway.com-3582-HC(Rajasthan)-GST

