The GST Appellate Tribunal at Lucknow exonerated an Ayodhya kirana trader, holding that order slips seized in a survey were temporary notes for sales that were exempt or duly recorded and taxed.

Loose handwritten order slips seized in a survey cannot sustain a demand under Section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017 where the trader shows that the sales were either exempt or recorded in its books and returns, the GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Lucknow has held [Manoj Traders v. Sanjay Kumar Pathak, Additional Commissioner Grade-II, U.P, 2026-juristway.com-3561-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST].

The Bench of Narendra Kumar, Member (Judicial), and Alok Chopra, Member (Technical), allowed the second appeal of a sole proprietorship dealing in kirana items, including taxable edible oil and sugar and exempt flour and maida.

On 24 Apr 2018 the Special Investigation Branch, Ayodhya, surveyed the premises, recorded stock worth ₹24,50,345 and seized loose order slips. An order of 28 Jun 2022 raised a total demand of ₹7,90,164, including tax of ₹1,44,375 each under CGST and SGST, interest and penalty. The first appellate authority, on 29 Dec 2025, reduced it, but sustained tax of ₹22,316.15 with equal penalty and interest.

The Tribunal found that the taxable sales on the slips were accounted for in the April 2018 sales register, and that the taxable turnover of ₹93,49,520, with CGST and SGST of ₹2,33,738.12 each, was reported in the GSTR‑3B for that month. The slips were temporary order notes, and the corresponding sales were either exempt or properly recorded in the books and returns.

The remaining demand was therefore held to have no legal basis. The order-in-appeal was set aside to the extent it confirmed tax, penalty and interest, the trader was fully exonerated for April 2018, and any amount paid is to be refunded in accordance with law.

2026-juristway.com-3561-GSTAT(Lucknow)-GST