Accepting the Justice Lodha Committee’s classification, the Supreme Court of India ordered sale certificates, refunds with 8% interest or civil suits for PACL allottees at Mohali and Bhatinda, depending on how they paid.
The Supreme Court has accepted the five categories into which the Justice (Retd.) R.M. Lodha Committee placed plot allottees of PACL’s residential projects at Sectors 100 and 104, Mohali and at Bhatinda, and has issued directions for each category according to how much was paid and whether it was paid through banking channels. [Subrata Bhattacharya v. Securities and Exchange Board of India & Ors., 2026-juristway.com-3779-SC-SEBI]
The Bench of Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar disposed of interlocutory applications in appeals arising from the finding of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) that PACL ran an unregistered collective investment scheme. By an order dated 2 Feb 2016 the Court had constituted the Committee to sell PACL’s land and refund investors.
Allottees who paid in full through banking channels are treated as buyers. The Recovery Officer under Section 28A of the SEBI Act is to issue them sale certificates or no-objection certificates within eight weeks, and possession certificates where none was issued.
Allottees who paid more than 50% through banking channels will receive, within eight weeks, a statement of the balance due and of their contribution to internal development works. They must pay within 30 days of receiving it, after which certificates are to issue within eight weeks. One extension of up to 30 days may be sought; otherwise the plot is treated as unsold and the audited amount refunded.
For those who paid less than 50%, residents’ associations asked to be allowed to pay the balance at market or circle rates. The Court declined, saying it could not convert the proceedings into suits for specific performance. “The best this Court can do now is conclude the proceedings” and ensure repayment with reasonable interest, it said. These allottees will get back the audited amount with interest at 8% within three months of a successful auction of the plot, in full satisfaction of their claims.
Applications by allottees who paid in cash, seeking allotment or refund, were rejected, but they may file civil suits for recovery or declaration. The Court will hear the amici curiae and SEBI on which parties may be impleaded in such suits. Allottees who paid through banks after 2 Feb 2016 will receive refunds with 8% interest on the same terms. Those who sold their allotments while the case was pending are to be dealt with under the category to which they would otherwise belong.
2026-juristway.com-3779-SC-SEBI



