The GSTAT Rajkot Bench set aside a ₹2.63 lakh Section 74 penalty on a brass rod maker, holding a GSTR‑2A mismatch is not suppression and penalty cannot stand without a tax demand.

A taxpayer that reverses excess input tax credit (ITC) before a show cause notice and pays interest within 30 days of it is covered by Section 73(8) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST Act), and no penalty is payable, the Rajkot Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) has held. [Manglam Metals v. Joint Commissioner (Appeals), Rajkot, 2026-juristway.com-3646-GSTAT(Rajkot)-GST]

The Bench of Pramod Kumar Rai, Member (Judicial), who wrote the order, and Kishori Lal, Member (Technical), heard the appeal as a Division Bench despite the small amount, because it raised a question of law under Section 109(8).

An audit found that the brass extrusion rod maker’s integrated tax ITC in Form GSTR‑3B for 2017-18 exceeded Form GSTR‑2A by ₹2,62,592. The firm reversed the full amount on 30 Apr 2022, before the final audit report. A notice of 30 Jun 2023 proposed only a penalty, and an equal penalty was imposed under Section 74(1).

The Tribunal held that Section 74 was not attracted. The firm held tax invoices and had paid its supplier, and the credit was missing from Form GSTR‑2A only because the supplier did not file returns. No one alleged fake invoices, non-receipt or collusion. A supplier’s default cannot be attributed to the recipient as fraud or suppression, and the condition in Section 16(2)(aa) took effect only from 1 Jan 2022.

Independently, it held that a Section 74 penalty is measured by the tax specified in the notice and determined under Section 74(9). Where the notice demands no tax, a penalty cannot be imposed in isolation.

Treating the case under Section 73 by virtue of Section 75(2), the Tribunal held that the reversal was a payment of tax of the kind in Section 73(5), whether or not prompted by audit. With interest paid on 28 Jul 2023, Section 73(8) applied. The appeal was allowed with refund of any pre-deposit and interest under Section 115.

2026-juristway.com-3646-GSTAT(Rajkot)-GST