The Delhi High Court held that a ₹49 lakh cash loan made in 2015 must be reported to tax authorities under the RBANMS ruling, but set aside a direction to file the plaintiff’s PAN card.

A civil court hearing a recovery suit founded on a large cash loan must send the case to the jurisdictional income tax authority even if the loan predates Section 269ST, but it cannot compel the plaintiff to disclose his permanent account number (PAN) card, the Delhi High Court has held. [Ashok Kumar v. Shri Bhagwan Transport Co & Ors., 2026-juristway.com-3645-HC(Delhi)-IT]

Justice Anish Dayal partly allowed a petition against orders of 11 Jul 2025 and 10 Oct 2025 of the District Judge, Rohini Courts, in a suit to recover ₹35,67,000. The plaint stated that ₹49,00,000 had been lent in cash on dates up to September 2015.

The trial court had acted on the Supreme Court’s ruling in RBANMS Educational Institution v. B. Gunashekar (2025 INSC 490), which requires courts to report cash transactions in breach of the Income Tax Act. The plaintiff argued that the ruling concerned Section 269ST, introduced in 2017, and did not reach a 2015 transaction.

With the help of an amicus curiae, the Court noted that Section 269SS, barring acceptance of loans and deposits in cash above set limits, had been in force since 1984, and that its object of curbing unaccounted money was recognised in Assistant Director of Inspection (Investigation) v. A.B. Shanthi (2002). Courts had reported pre-2017 transactions in line with the purpose of RBANMS, and since the transaction was a loan, the reporting was appropriate.

The direction to file a PAN card was a different matter. RBANMS issued no such direction, and the card carries personal details protected by the right to informational privacy recognised in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India (2017).

The PAN direction was set aside, and a copy of the suit with relevant documents is to be sent to the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi. The Court clarified that the reporting is only to inform the tax authorities and should not hold up the trial, which is to be decided on its merits.

2026-juristway.com-3645-HC(Delhi)-IT