The Delhi High Court dismissed a domestic polystyrene producer’s challenge to the Centre’s refusal to impose anti-dumping duty, upholding Section 9A(1) and the public-interest reasons in the 2020 office memorandum.

The Central Government’s power under Section 9A(1) of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 not to impose anti-dumping duty (ADD) despite a positive recommendation of the Designated Authority is a valid discretion, and its exercise on public-interest grounds will not be disturbed if founded on relevant material, the Delhi High Court has held. [Supreme Petrochem Ltd. v. Union of India & Anr., 2026-juristway.com-3673-HC(Delhi)-Customs]

The Division Bench of Justice Anil Kshetarpal and Justice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar, in a judgment by Justice Kshetarpal, dismissed a domestic producer’s petition challenging Section 9A(1) and Rule 18 of the Anti-Dumping Rules of 1995 as violating Article 14, and an office memorandum of 11 Nov 2020.

The Designated Authority had recommended definitive ADD on polystyrene from Iran, Malaysia, Singapore, Chinese Taipei, the UAE and the USA in its final findings of 12 Jun 2020. The Centre chose not to impose it.

The Court held that Article 9.1 of the WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement leaves the decision to impose duty to the importing country. The Act implements this through a two-stage process in which technical determination by the Designated Authority and policy discretion of the Government operate in sequence, so the provisions are not unguided or arbitrary.

On merits, the Designated Authority’s mandate is limited to dumping, injury and the causal link. The Government considered different matters: the interests of downstream users, the availability of alternative supply at competitive prices and the risk of the domestic industry becoming a duopoly. One of only three domestic producers had stopped operating after a fire, and the Government had obtained an assessment from NITI Aayog and other agencies on the demand-supply impact. This material bore a rational nexus to its decision.

Holding the discretion legislative or quasi-legislative in character, the Court declined to interfere and dismissed the petition. Three other petitions on different products, heard with it, were directed to be listed separately on 8 Jan 2027.

2026-juristway.com-3673-HC(Delhi)-Customs