Restoring a Single Judge’s order, the Supreme Court of India held that GMB Ceramics had referred only a ₹2 crore claim to arbitration, so an ₹11.69 crore award against Neycer could not stand.
The Supreme Court has held that an arbitrator or umpire cannot confer jurisdiction on himself by misconstruing the terms of the reference, and that whether a claim falls within the reference is for the court to decide on an objective reading of the documents, not a matter of the umpire’s “plausible” view. [Neycer (India) Ltd. v. GMB Ceramics Ltd., 2026-juristway.com-3775-SC-INDLAW]
Justice Dipankar Datta authored the judgment for a Bench that included Justice Satish Chandra Sharma. The appeals arose from objections under Sections 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 to an umpire’s award dated 23 Jun 1999.
The dispute arose from an agreement dated 29 Nov 1986 under which Neycer was to provide know-how and technical services for GMB’s plant. The umpire awarded GMB ₹11,69,62,910 with interest at 15% per annum. On 14 Oct 2015 a Single Judge of the Calcutta High Court restricted the award to ₹2,00,00,000. On 24 Sep 2018 a Division Bench restored it in full, treating the umpire’s reading of the correspondence before the reference as a plausible one.
The Court examined that correspondence. GMB had repeatedly quantified its project cost overrun at ₹2 crore, and its telex dated 19 Oct 1989 nominating its arbitrator defined the reference by that claim. A later letter that merely reserved the right to claim other losses could not enlarge the reference. Neycer had pleaded the objection from the start, so contesting the claims on merits was not a waiver.
The Court also agreed with the Single Judge that the award of damages for loss of the brand name was speculative, resting on an advertising agency’s estimate that no witness proved. It held that Clause 20 of the agreement, under which Neycer “shall endeavour” to commission the plant within 18 months, could not be read as a guarantee underwriting GMB’s profitability and debt servicing for five years.
Neycer’s plea that even the ₹2 crore should go was rejected, as it invited the Court to re-appreciate evidence and substitute its own reading of the agreement for the umpire’s.
The Division Bench judgment was set aside and the Single Judge’s order restored. The ₹4 crore that Neycer deposited under interim orders, being ₹2 crore each towards principal and interest, and that GMB withdrew in January 2019, stands adjusted in full and final satisfaction of the award. The parties bear their own costs.
2026-juristway.com-3775-SC-INDLAW



