The Meghalaya High Court held that a notice attached to Form DRC‑01 substantially complied with Section 73(1), dismissing a dealer’s writ, but allowed a late appeal to meet the ends of justice.
A taxpayer who knew of the show cause notice and the hearing date but did not reply or appear cannot claim lack of jurisdiction or denial of natural justice where the procedure substantially complied with Section 73(1) of the Meghalaya Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (MGST Act), the Meghalaya High Court has held. [B.S. Automobiles v. State of Meghalaya & Ors., 2026-juristway.com-3677-HC(Meghalaya)-GST]
The Division Bench of Justice H.S. Thangkhiew and Justice B. Bhattacharjee, in a judgment by Justice Thangkhiew, heard a motor parts dealer’s challenge to an assessment order of 27 Feb 2025 confirming ₹19,90,088 for 2020-21, and recovery notices of 5 Mar 2026 and 31 Mar 2026.
The dealer argued that no statutory show cause notice was served before the summary in Form GST DRC‑01, in breach of Section 73(1) and Rule 142(1), that the hearing dates were inconsistent and that the orders were unsigned.
The State said a notice dated 28 Nov 2024 specifying the tax period and amounts was attached to Form GST DRC‑01, that the figures matched the scrutiny notice in Form GST ASMT‑10 to which the dealer had replied on 21 Sep 2024, and that a hearing was fixed on 13 Dec 2024. It pointed out that Section 73(1) prescribes no form for the notice itself, and that the appeal period had expired.
The Court held that the notice and hearing date were within the dealer’s knowledge, and that it neither replied nor appeared, nor appealed even after recovery notices. The procedure was in substantial compliance and within jurisdiction, and no breach of natural justice arose. The writ petition, filed after long unexplained delay beyond the limits in Sections 107(1) and 107(5), failed on maintainability.
Even so, to meet the ends of justice and without it serving as a precedent, the Court permitted the dealer to appeal under Section 107 against the assessment order and recovery notices within four weeks.
2026-juristway.com-3677-HC(Meghalaya)-GST

